Part 3 - How I fucked a very religious girl, and turned her into a slut, also losing [m]y virginity. With Voyeur/Exhibitionist moments! (THE END) | 2016

Continued from Part 2: http://www.reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/1pz87c/part_2_how_i_fucked_a_very_religious_girl_and/

I'm freaking out. I have no idea what's about to happen and walk out of the bathroom to find Tiffany, panty-clad with her tits out taking more shots with Emily, who now has her top off too. Emily's sweet tits briefly distracted me from my concerns, as they were surprisingly perky and she had those tiny pink nipples that made them aesthetically pleasing. Clark and Gary were enjoying the show, the girls bouncing around, tits and asses jiggling. The girls, obviously enjoying the attention, continue to jump around and giggle. I jump in and offer to take a shot. Emily steps forward and tells me to bend down so I can hear her, I oblige and she says "only if you take those boxers off so we can see what you got too," winking at me. Desperate to get Tiffany alone so I can break the news to her, I oblige, followed by the three of us taking a shot. Clark and Gary are laying back, watching the show, obviously discussing how things will proceed. I nodded over to them, then motioned to Tiffany to come with me to the basement. I grabbed two beers and head downstairs, cock out and everything. If I hadn't been as stressed, I probably would've thought more about being nude. I'm holding Tiffany up as we're walking downstairs, when she grabs my cock again. I sit her up and we talk briefly. I buck up my courage and tell her what happened to the condom. She laughed at my disclosure and nervousness. She told me that she had a specific medical issue that made it impossible to get pregnant. I then mentioned STD's to her and she continued to chuckle and mentioned her and Brian had been each others' firsts, and that they'd only had sex three times and only in the past 2 months, and that up until then they'd been woefully afraid of any sex, much less STD engaging in risque STD-type behavior. I told her then that she was my first as well. She looked a bit surprised and commented that I was much better than Brian who awkwardly and unrhythymically humped her pussy with what she described as an unfulfilling cock. She also confessed that she'd recently began masturbating and looking at porn. She found out that she liked it rough and kind of enjoyed the idea of being a "naughty slut." She also thought that Brian just wasn't a good sexual match for her in a more general sense, but that he tried to treat her as a "princess" and wasn't forceful enough (i.e., he'd only fuck her in missionary, little to no foreplay, etc.). I nodded along, listening to her tell her story, half in a daze of relief and half paying attention to the sexy details. She catches my full attention when she tells me how grateful she is for having someone eat her pussy, because she's never had someone do that before and it was really good for her, and that she's never sucked a dick before because Brian thought it was too dirty for good Christian people to do. No longer thinking my world was fucked and listening to her sexy thoughts and history got my cock rising again. My semi-erect cock becoming visible to both of us, I comment that if she'd like to give dick-sucking a shot, she was welcome to have a first of her own.

Without hesitation, she dropped to her knees and started licking at the bottom of my shaft. My cock is regaining steam watching her pretty face learn how to orally please a cock. She licked up and down the shaft, unsure of what to do. Sensing the moment, I leaned on the handful of blowjobs I'd gotten in the past and porn to guide the way. I massaged her head gently, allowing my hands to cup her head and gently eased her face above my cock rather than at the side of it and firmly told to "take as much of my dick as you can until gag." She gave me a worried look, but shoved her throat onto the head of my cock, probably about halfway down, then pulling back. I told her that it wasn't a one time deal. I then, step by step, teach her how to deepthroat given her limited skills. Suddenly, she pulls off and informs me that it turns her on to gag on cock. Wanting to oblige, having more wits about me, and having one orgasm under my belt, I order her to lie down on the basement table on her back, and approach her face while I'm standing. I pull her face down so that her head is hanging from the table and place my cock on her chin. "Take my cock into your mouth." She obliges, gently pressing her lips around the now rock-hard head of my cock. I shove my cock as hard as I can down her throat, hitting her gag reflex with inches to spare. I pull it out of her mouth and ask, "is that what you like, Tiffany?" She nods yes. I shove my cock back into her mouth, and place my hands on her jiggling tits, grabbing them roughly. I start to pickup the pace that I'm fucking her throat, making it continually expand to take more of my cock. As I'm starting to really go at it with reckless abandon, I notice Gary has heard the gagging noises and is watching us. Tiffany, occupied, does not notice Gary. He nods at me as if to say "I'm not even here." I nod over at Gary, who has a nice view of Tiffany's wet thong, my playing with her tits, and her throat periodically bulging with my cock filling it. I start to go slow, deliberate, and grind my cock into her gag reflex, periodically checking to make sure she's okay and reminding her to breathe through her nose. Again, I take a moment to enjoy myself and the crazy scene, the pretty conservative Christian girl has taken to gagging on cock WITH ME. Coming out of my stupor, I realize that Gary is down with us. I motion for Tiffany, a bit cock crazed to sit up. She now sees Gary and briefly looks surprised, but then seems to immediately lose that sense of shame that used to accompany her. She had just let a stranger watch her get fucked in the mouth and she had already let a stranger watch a man shoot his load into her. I don't think that people choose a moment to "go bad" but if I had to pinpoint Tiffany's, this would be it. I ask Gary if he brought any booze down with him, nods over at the bottle of Captain Morgan's that's stayed down in the basement. The three of us take a quick shot. We then talk dirty and Gary asks if Tiffany will fuck him tonight too. She pauses, taken aback a bit and politely declines that offer. She says taking on two guys is a bit much more than she thought she could take, but that since she'd already been watched and liked it, she was cool letting Gary watch us. Gary, looking a bit bummed, nods but then Tiffany says "well, I guess if you want to jerk off while we're here, I'd love to watch a guy do that," and winks at him. Gary, seeming to perk up a bit, nods and takes a seat at the table I'd just mouth-fucked Tiffany on. I walk Tiffany over to a couch, adjacent from the table Gary's now sitting at. I lean down and kiss up her neckline, to her face and say "I'm going to fuck you senseless," She moans and nods for me to go ahead. I lick my way down her chest, stopping at each nipple, licking each briefly, finding my way down, expecting her to need a warm up before we start fucking again and am happy to find that I could probably wring an entire shots out of wetness from her panties (between my load earlier and her juices from being throat-fucked). I pull those panties off her and throw them on a floor. I pull Tiffany's long legs up in the air and spread them out, allowing Gary a pleasant view of her swollen pussy. I continue with Tiffany, teasing her. I lick around her clit and labia in circles over and over until I see her hips buck, at which point I immediately start licking and sucking her clit, watching her writhe, moaning and pushing her pussy into my mouth. I pull back a bit and shove two fingers into her being sure to lean to give Gary a good view of my fingers spreading apart her hopelessly tight snatch. Tiffany is even more responsive than last time, her hips instantly bucking to my fingers' entry, letting out another guttural moan. I pump my fingers in and out, twisting them around, doing my best to loosen her up again. I look up at Tiffany and see that she's locked eyes with Gary, who has his hand in his pants and is obviously stroking himself. Not wanting to disappoint, I flip Tiffany over and put her in front of me with her ass in the air, sliding in front of her, I take my mostly hard cock and face-fuck her a bit, letting it hit her gag reflex a couple of times to get myself fully hard. I look down to gauge her reaction, and I see her fully lustful. She's looking sideways at Gary, who's now down to his boxers and stroking himself. Taking the cues, I now position myself behind

Tiffany and rub her wetness up and down her pussy lips to lubrciate my entry, briefly considering my luck to be able to fuck her without a condom at all, and place the head of my now throbbing cock between her labia. I look at Gary, and forcefully slide as much of my cock as Tiffany's barely used pussy can accomodate, causing her to let out a shriek, and Gary to stroke himself harder while watching me stretch Tiffany out. I grind myself against Tiffany's insides, pressing my cock into her depths before taking it nearly all out and shoving it back in rough. Tiffany starts spasming, bucking on all 4's against my strokes. Sensing she's near an orgasm, I grab her neck with one hand, and reach around to her tits with my other hand, before I start using all my might to pound her silly. Gary later described the look on her face as "pure enthusiasm, nearly oblivious to everything around her, but obviously fulfilled." After about 20-30 seconds of some of the roughest, deepest strokes I've ever delivered, Tiffany's body nearly has a seizure, causing me to have to hold onto her hips to stay inside her, I feel everything in her tighten up, her pussy clamps my cock down and feels as if it's milking me. I'm blown away from the sensation of this girl losing herself on my cock and my eyes roll back in my head. At that moment, it was taking every ounce of my self-control to avoid shooting another load deep inside Tiffany. After what seemed like an eternity, Tiffany collapses onto her stomach. She lies down and looks over at Gary, causing me to do the same and Gary's stopped stroking himself, his cock now free from his boxers and hanging, fully erect in the air.

I asked Gary what he'd like to see to finish things off, looking down at Tiffany, seemingly exhausted and spent. He asks "Tiff, you had him or Brian fuck your ass yet?" Tiffany instantly perks up and says "not yet..." Gary and I are both grinning like hell now. The thought of fucking this sweet, previously innocent girl in her brown eye nearly makes me cum on the spot. I immediately start grabbing her ass, massaging it, making sure to periodically slide a finger or two inside her now well-worn pussy to help encourage her to make a decision. We talk it over and she decides that she'll give it a shot, but while looking at my cock, expresses some reservations and was unsure if it would happen since she's never even popped a finger in her back door. She says she'll do it but wants to be able to shut it down at any point and that if she passes out, to not continue. Gary and I both look at each other, giving a mental high-five and tell her that her that of course her wishes will be respected.

Having watched enough amateur porn, I know I need to lube and prep before even thinking about penetration. I flip her back over, and start licking her from clit to her pucker and back, over and over again, being sure to leave lots of spit. I take two fingers and start grinding them into her pussy, rubbing her anal cavity from the bottom wall. Seeing her moan, looking a bit nervous, I gingerly add a third into her pussy and watch her nervousness immediately shift into enthusiasm. "Go ahead and slide a finger in my ass." I indulge her and gently push my middle finger slowly into her asshole Glancing over at Gary, slowly jerking himself, intently watching. I take a peek at Tiffany and she's smiling as I slide my finger in and out, still enjoying herself. I do this, while using my other hand to rub her clit for a couple of minutes until she approvingly bucks her hips. I can tell she's ready. I add a 2nd finger and repeat my motions. Gary starts to make more noises, picking up his speed in anticipation. I lean down and whisper to Tiffany "are you ready?" It taks her a while to respond, barely able to pay attention to anything other than the sensations, she nods at me and says "go slow." I remove my fingers and position myself behind her, first shoving myself back into her pussy to lube it back up. She moans and says playfully protests "wrong hole!" biting her lip, smiling and looking back at me. I pull back out, reposition the bulging head of my cock at her ass, doing my best not to let my nervousness ruin the experience. I lean forward and whisper to her "rub your clit and this will be better." She acknowledges and I feel her hand near my balls, rubbing herself. I push gently at first, but cannot enter. I then push a bit harder and hear a light "POP" noise, Tiffany cries out "oooooooo!" her face visibly straining with her struggling to adjust her asshole to accomodate my throbbing cock. When my cockhead pulses, she ever so lightly recoils each time. I sit with just the head in for a second, waiting for her approval to proceed, when I look over at Gary and he's rapidly stroking his cock, staring at Tiffany's face. Tiffany looks back and approves a couple more inches. I slide about halfway in and start pressing myself in and out, I look at Tiffany's face, she's frigging her clit at rapid speed and it looks like she's starting to enjoy herself. A bit more relaxed, she looks over at Gary and sexily groans out at him "you just got to watch me lose my anal cherry, do you like watching him fuck me?" Gary nods at her, starting to spasm. I motion for him to come over, Tiffany looks at him and then at me and nods at Gary, visibly about to expell his nuts. Tiffany pulls herself upright enough and allows Gary to spill his cum all over her pretty, formerly innocent face. I didn't know much about Gary sexually, but that guy can shoot a load. He let out what seemed like rope after rope, covering her eyes, nose, cheeks, mouth, hair, etc. As this is happening, Tiffany unwittingly pushed herself back over the entirety of my cock. She starts screaming, frigging her likely engorged clit, clenches her ass muscles around my cock, and starts spasming, even letting out a little gush. The scene of her taking her first facial, coupled with the sensation of being totally engulfed by the first asshole I'd ever fucked, sends me into my own orgasm, while I sent several ropes of my own deep into her no-longer-virginal ass. My cock shrinking, both of us exhausted collapse onto each other. Gary claps slowly, thanks us and walks up to see what Emily and Clark are doing. Tiffany and I pass out on the couch in a weird tangled pile of exhausted, well-fucked human flesh.

Endnote: I only talked to Tiffany once during college about a year later over instant messenger. She told me that she'd dropped out of the Christian college she had agreed to attend and was thinking about getting into porn. I heard later that she moved out of the country and completely lost touch with her. I'll never forget that night, Gary and I still chuckle about it when we periodically meet up (we weren't great friends, just acquaintances really). Emily and Clark apparently fucked through the morning that night and let Gary continue to watch them, eventually blowing Gary to finish his evening. Darrel later told us that Cheryl made a point of impaling herself on his cock, but they then went to the same party Gary left and she fucked 2 more guys that he knows of, maybe more. I'm happy to answer any questions you guys might have, aside from identity, picture requests, etc. Thanks for reading and I hope you enjoyed my first crack at this.