Next story of me, my girlfriend, and a NEW buddy! (M)(F)(M) | 2016

So sadly about a month after our last story, Nicole, Joey and I graduated high school. He got a girlfriend that summer, and was unable to continue playing with us. He went to a college far away, while Nicole and I stayed local for college together. Our freshman year of college did not have much play time with other guys for her, but sophomore year brought us back into the swing of things.

I had moved off campus into an apartment, and my roommates schedule was dead opposite of mine, so Nicole and I had free run of the place a lot of the time. It had been over a year since we had played last with Joey, and we had talked about bringing in another guy. I approached a friend of mine named Kevin who went to the same school, who I had a similar background with to Joey. He was more than thrilled to come join us. Nicole and I hadn’t used a condom in years, and she was really dreading the idea of having to use condoms with Kevin. We asked Kevin if he was willing to prove he was clean if we were. He was willing and clean, as were we. Therefore, we decided as a group that condoms would not be required.

We picked a day when my roommate was at work and we 3 did not have class to first meet (Nicole and Kevin had never met, just seen pictures of each other). Nicole was very excited the morning of our “date” with Kevin. She shaved herself fully bare, and got dressed in her most sexy lingerie, a nice pink teddy and a silk pink thong. She hopped into bed and turned on some porn to help her get in the mood. Kevin texted saying he was parking at our complex now, and I asked Nicole if she was ready. She motioned for me to come over to the bed, where she planted on me one of the most passionate kisses I have ever felt.

I heard the doorbell ring, and walked to the front door to let Kevin in. We explained pleasantries, and walked to the bedroom. As we walked in, Nicole was putting the laptop away, still under the covers in bed. I reached over and pulled the covers down, revealing her gorgeous body covered in skimpy lingerie to Kevin, who gave a smile of approval. Kevin said it wasn’t fair that she was down to lingerie and we were fully dressed, so he suggested both us guys strip down to our boxers and join us in bed.

With Nicole in the middle of the bed, Kevin and I each took a side. Nicole arched her head back and moaned as Kevin and my hands explored her body – I could tell she missed the attention of two men! I helped her out of the teddy, as Kevin removed her silk thong. He ran his hands over her clean shaven pussy and ass, a huge smile on his face. At the same time, I was working on her breasts with my mouth, sucking and licking, making her squirm. I moved down and took over for Kevin at her pussy, starting to eat her out. Kevin moved up towards her face, and as I looked up I could see her excitement as she slid his cock out of his boxers. Now as you know from my previous stories, I am 6 inches, and Joey was 6 inches but thicker than me. Kevin on the other hand was a solid 8 inches, and just as thick if not thicker than Joey.

She eagerly took his cock into her mouth, as I continued to eat her pussy. She was not used to such a big cock, and was having to work hard to suck. I was getting a good laugh out of it. She apologized to Kevin for struggling, and he simply laughed and said “practice makes perfect” to which she replied by sucking even harder. I stopped eating her pussy and moved up on the bed next to her, opposite of Kevin. She reached over and started stroking my cock, eventually alternating between sucking and stroking Kevin and I.

I asked Kevin if he wanted to try out her tight pussy, to which of course he said yes. We switched positions, him lying down on the bed, and Nicole eased herself down onto his big cock, bareback. I was kneeling on the bed next to her, face to face as I could see the pain/pleasure his cock was giving her as she eased down onto it. Once her pussy was adjusted to the size, she started to ride him with a great rhythm. She would occasionally reach over and stroke my cock, kiss me, or just stare into my eyes, but his big cock was giving her so much pleasure I could tell she was having a hard time focusing on two things at once.

Kevin said he was getting close to cumming after a few minutes, and asked if he could cum inside her pussy. She looked at me, and basically simultaneously we said of course. She kept the same great rhythm going, and within a minute I could tell by the look on their faces that he was cumming inside of her pussy. After he was finished, she eased herself off of him and laid down on the bed between us again. Kevin excused himself to the bathroom to clean up, and Nicole and I embraced passionately. She smiled and said she felt so dirty, having another man’s cum inside her pussy, but that she loved it and had missed that feeling since our last time with Joey. She told me she loved me, and I told her I loved her. She asked me for a bottle of water, and I excused myself to go upstairs to the kitchen.

When I walked back into the bedroom, much to my surprise – I found out that Kevin is one of those guys who can go multiple times – he did not go soft after cumming! Nicole was laying on her back on the bed, with her pussy near the edge, and Kevin was standing and fucking her! She smiled as I handed her the bottle of water, apologizing for starting again without me. I said it was not a problem, and replaced the bottle of water in her mouth with my cock. Now Nicole and I had been practicing anal for a few months – she was slowly getting used to it. We had talked about DP before, and done it with toys. I asked if she wanted to try it, and she said she wasn’t sure if we would fit, considering her toys were nowhere as big as Kevin’s cock. But she said she would try!

She instructed Kevin to lay down on the bed, and climbed on top of him, taking his cock into her sloppy pussy once again. I grabbed our lube and poured some on her ass and my cock, lubing them both up nicely. I slipped a finger into her butt, while she sat still, and Kevin slowly would move in and out of her. After working in two fingers slowly, I grabbed her butt plug. I slowly put it in after coating it in lube. Once she was able to take the butt plug, she asked me to replace it with my cock.

As I entered her slowly, I could hear her moaning, and could feel Kevin’s cock slowly moving in and out of her pussy through the thin wall. It was fantastically erotic and tight, as she was moaning and screaming in pleasure and slight pain. After a few minutes of us each going very slowly, she said she was ready for more, and Kevin and I picked up our pace and built a nice rhythm.

Now Nicole had only ever cum through her vibrator on her clit. She wasn’t sure, but I felt her pussy and ass convulse in what felt like an orgasm a few times as we DPed her. The last convulsion on her part led to my cock exploding in her ass, shooting my load up her ass for the first time ever. Nicole excused herself off of Kevin, and ran to the bathroom a little bit embarrassed to clean up the two loads of cum in her body. As she came out of the bathroom, she greeted Kevin on her knees and took his cock into her mouth, sucking him. At this point in time, she still could not deepthroat and did not swallow or take cum in her mouth. Kevin asked if she would, and she shook her head no. She still sucked until he was close, and had him pull out and shoot his second load of the day onto her tits.

At that point Kevin dressed and we walked him to the door (was really hot watching Nicole fully nude, her tits covered in cum, and some cum still dripping out of her ass and pussy running down her legs, walk to the front door). She said thank you, and that she would love to have him again, and he said likewise.

As we closed the door, she turned to me and said she wanted to work on swallowing and deepthroating. I gladly agreed to help her! More on that in our next story.