Olivia and Michelle's orgasm competition OR the most I have ever cum [Group][MFMF] | 2016

This is a continuation of my bowl game story posted here https://www.reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/83y2yc/bowl_game_fun_ffm_or_how_my_girlfriends_best/

So it was the week before the fall semester in August, and spent a week homeless living at my friend Josh’s apartment while he was visiting his parents out of town. I had waited too long to search for an apartment off campus and had signed a lease for the new apartment, but they were still painting and renovating it, so it was not ready.

My friend Josh returns home Friday morning before the semester starts, and I am to move in to my new place in the same apartment complex on Saturday. So Friday night we both have to crash in his 1 bedroom apartment.

Josh knew Olivia through my girlfriend Michelle, because Josh and I partied together probably 2-4 times a week. Toward the end of July and they were kind of in between FWB’s and actually dating. I hadn’t yet told Josh the previous story because Michelle and I always thought that he and Olivia had some chemistry and we didn’t want to get in the way of things. Anyway, I don’t remember the details of going out that night, but I would assume that we probably drank at one or multiple places on campus where the girls could get away with being 20, while we were both 21. The four of us end up back at Josh’s with my future roommate Jeff. Jeff is the kind of person who’s not a bad guy, but is kind of awkward around people, doesn’t necessarily add anything to the group, and doesn’t know when to leave.

We are having a last couple of beers when Jeff invites himself to sleep on Josh’s floor uninvited. Michelle and I are supposed to sleep on the pullout couch and Olivia and Josh will sleep in the bedroom. Michelle is kind of pissed, but when Jeff decides to do something there’s not much we can do.

I don’t remember what our excuse is, but the four of us decide to ditch Jeff and go into the bedroom and lock the door. I think we were hoping he would leave, but we knew he probably wouldn’t.

Josh notices how messy his sheets and comforter are and asked if we broke his one rule while he was gone, which was no sex in his bed. I said “It’s not like I got any cum on it, you’ll be alright” He was still kinda mad, but also kinda playing up being mad as a joke, but Josh goes to his computer and starts making a winamp playlist of songs downloaded on limewire.

I’m laying in bed while Olivia is drunkenly crawling through the sheets pretending to look for stains from the sex Michelle and I had, and then at some point Michelle turns out the lights and proclaims “We are going to break your rule again, you better look away”

I start loudly unbuckling my shorts to play along, when I feel a tug pull them all the way down. I feel Olivia take my cock and deep throat it until I get hard, and then she hands it off to Michelle who is also under the covers at this point, while Olivia pretend to “smell” a cum stain.

Josh then gets in bed “to prevent sex from happening”, and we are all laying there in order Josh Olivia, Me, Michelle. I turn and face Michelle so that my rock hard erection isn’t pitching a tent in the covers, and Michelle is slowly playing with me and teasing my head. The four of us are kind of talking and calming down, and then Josh’s computer monitor goes to sleep and it gets pitch black and silent. We have about 5 really long awkward seconds until I blirt out “Let’s play who’s in my mouth” Which was the punch line to a Dane Cook joke. Everyone starts crying laughing (Dane cook was still funny back then) Meanwhile, I can hear Olivia trying to silently take of Josh’s pants, through the laughter. She starts making out with Josh, and stroking him. Somehow, I start feeling competitive, so I stick my hand down Michelle’s pants and my fingers find my way to her slippery clit, and I start rubbing it. She starts making out with me to muffle her moans, but Olivia and Josh can definitely hear her. Michelle then gets up and says I need to go to the restroom, and Olivia follow her.

Josh and I awkwardly try to hide our dicks from each other under the covers and play it off like neither one of us has our pants down. When the door opens back up, Michelle walks out with the bathroom light illuminating her naked body and sillouette of her massive DD’s and small waste. Olivia follows behind her with her large B small C tits punctuated by fully erect perky nipples.

Olivia rips off the covers and says “You better fuck the shit out of us” and takes Josh’s cock all the way down her throat.

Michelle has turned the bathroom light back off and starts blowing me as well, but she arranges everyone so that she has access to Olivia’s ass, and she starts fingering Olivia was both girls continue to blow us. Michelle then spits on my dick and starts titty fucking me because she’s not the best at blow jobs, but she knows she can make up for it.

I can tell Josh is still a little uneasy about this, but Olivia then starts riding him cow girl and says “ You better make me cum more than Michelle cums” and now that we are in competition he starts getting into it.

Michelle gets into position and I get behind her and start pounding her doggy, because I know it makes her cum quick, but as she starts ramping up, Olivia is vigorously riding Josh and gets off first. Her moans set off Michelle and Michelle starts cumming during the end of Olivia’s orgasm.

She’s still riding him and says “1 to…. 1” in rhythm.

I reach down and start pinching and pulling on Michelle’s nipple with my left hand and pulling her hair with my right, and I am able to get her to cum again pretty quickly. As she’s cumming, Olivia flips over, puts her ass in the air and says “Put a finger in my ass.” Josh obliges and Olivia starts to squeal, and cums again.

I flip Michelle over and start into standing missionary on the side of the bed, I know Michelle is good for one or maybe two more if I’m lucky. Olivia, is now cumming for a third time, and I start to rub Michelle’s clit, to move things along faster, but she pushes my hand out of the way and starts rubbing her clit hardcore. Her pussy starts getting so much wetter, and the she reaches across her chest with her other arm, to pinch and pull her opposite nipple while squeezing her tits together, she starts moaning, but I realize I am about to bust. I hold on through the loudest orgasm I have ever heard from her and then pull out and shower her tits with cum. My first rope gets to her bottom lip, and then successive shots just keep covering her tits. It’s the biggest load I’ve ever put on her, and I can see her start to smile as the last drops are dropping out.

As she’s licking her lips and cleaning off my tip, Olivia starts pulling josh’s hips until he is thrusting as hard and as fast as he can, as she plays with her clit to cum and seal the victory, but Josh pulls out half way through and cums on her back.

Olivia smiles and says “we won” but Michelle says “You didn’t finish your orgasm, it’s a tie” They start to argue about it, on the way to the bathroom until the light comes on and Olivia says “HOLY SHIT, I’ve never seen that much cum! I didn’t think it was possible to actually complete cover your boobs!”

Josh and Olivia stopped talking about a week later. I ended up breaking up with Michelle at the end of college. Olivia and I had this weird FWB thing after college where at 2 am if we weren’t hooking up with someone else, she would try to make me cum as much as that night, but she wanted me to cum down her throat. I could never live up to it, because I like all body types but I’m still a tits man