18F [M]y [F]irst [F]ourso[m]e | 2016

Last month I posted on r/dirtypenpals about the foursome I had for my birthday. Someone told me I should post the story on here but I never did. Now, I’m bored spending my Thanksgiving in the middle of nowhere with the family so I figured I’d come back on here and kill some time. Rather than write out the story, I’ll just copy/paste some of the more common questions I got on DPP along with the answers. I tried my best to put them in some kind of logical order. I’ll be around for the next few days so if you want to know more, PM me. It will keep me entertained at least.

How did the idea come about? I started thinking about it a little after my 17th birthday. I wanted to have an 18th birthday to remember and a foursome seemed like a good way to do that.

Who was involved and how old is everyone? It was me (just turned 18), my good friend Kaylie (18), a guy we know from school Jon (17), and his buddy Eric (19).

How did everyone get involved? Was it planned or spontaneous? This was very much planned by me. I basically asked each of them to be a part of it, though it wasn’t easy. Kaylie was more of a backup plan. She was the first girl I asked but she didn’t want to do it. She said that she would join only if I couldn’t find another girl. I tried but as it turns out, girls my age aren’t really into that sort of thing. In the end, Kaylie had to live up to her promise. Jon was the easiest. He and I had fooled around a little before and jumped at the opportunity. Finding a second guy proved just as difficult as finding a girl. They were all for it until they realized that another guy was involved. It didn’t look like it was going to happen until Jon mentioned his buddy Eric would probably be interested. At that point, I was in a beggars can’t be choosers situation and had to take him even though neither Kaylie nor I really knew this guy.

Why didn't Kaylie want to do it? She's not into the whole casual sex thing. She has a boyfriend who she has sex with all the time, but just hasn't been one to sleep around a lot.

Where did it take place? Although I wanted it to happen during my actual birthday weekend, Kaylie’s parent’s had an out of town trip planned the following week. We waited until then since we would have the place to ourselves. We all still live with our parents so it’s not like it’s easy to find a spot to do something like this. As far as where it happened in the house, in the living room.

What does everyone look like? I’m fairly tall at 5’7”, 135 lbs, brunette with shoulder length hair, brown eyes, light skinned puerto rican/white mixed, pretty long legs that I get complimented on, pierced belly button, curvy hips, 34D breasts with an ass that leaves a little something to be desired :(

Kaylie is 5’6”, ~115 lbs, long blonde hair, blue eyes, marvelous ass, nicely cut stomach, shapely legs, pierced belly button, pierced tongue, pierced clit, one pierced nipple, 32B breasts. She definitely turns heads.

Jon is ~5’6”, 140 lbs (guessing), skinny, not really cut, more of a runner’s body. White, blonde hair, blue eyes, cute round butt.

Eric is 5’8” (maybe not quite but a little taller than me), ~165, slightly muscular with a nice firm chest. Not sure about nationality but I think he’s middle eastern, nicely maintained beard, copper toned skin, slicked black hair, quite a bit of body hair.

How did everything get started? I came up with a game that would avoid any awkwardness or pressure to make the first move. We played spin the bottle, but instead of just kissing the person the bottle pointed to, we also got to remove a piece of clothing from them. Once enough clothing was gone, things just happened naturally from there.

So who was the first one to get totally naked? Jon. I don't think he really thought about it beforehand because the rest of us wore a couple extra articles of clothing. Also, the bottle seemed to keep landing on him so I guess he was just lucky/un-lucky.

Who had the nicer cock? They were both pretty nice and fun to play with. Eric isn’t circumcised which I hadn’t encountered before so that was new. They both shaved themselves which made giving them head a lot better. Hadn’t realized how much of a difference it could make since it’s the first time I’ve been with a guy that has shaved himself.

Did either you or Kaylie get a creampie? Did either of you eat it out of each other? No creampies. Condoms were used so if the guys did finish while fucking us, it was inside of a condom. Otherwise they would pull out and cum somewhere on us.

Who did you fuck the most? I think we all fucked each other pretty evenly.

Who came first? Kaylie was the first to orgasm.

Was that your first sexual experience? Definitely not, lol

Had you ever fooled around with your friend Kaylee before or was that the first time? No, this was the first time she and I have done anything other than kissing. I’ve seen her naked before but that’s about it.

Were either of you nervous? What did you both do to each other? I can't speak for her but I wasn't nervous. We kissed, played with each other's breasts, fingered each other, went down on each other. Really as much as two girls can do with each other.

Which one was your favorite to fuck and why? Kaylie simply because I had never done that much with another girl before.

How many orgasms did you have ? I didn’t orgasm at all but it was still a lot of fun. It takes quite a bit to get me to cum and with everything going on, there wasn’t a point where I was able to focus on it to make it happen.

Did you and/or Kaylie get DP’d? Did you/she enjoy it? Yes, we both did. I personally love getting DP’d. I had to convince Kaylie to try it and once she did, I could tell she wasn’t fully enjoying it. I doubt she’d do it again but glad that she at least tried it.

Did you get to taste either of the guy's cum? Did one taste better than the other? They both came in my mouth at one point or another. Can’t say that one tasted better than the other. They both just tasted like cum.

What part of the whole foursome didn't you like? Was there at any point you thought "I'd be happier if this weren't happening right now"? I enjoyed the entire thing. Nothing that I regret or would change.

Where did the guys cum? They both came multiple times so they came in multiple places. Face, mouth, breasts, ass, stomach. It was kind of all over the place. Eric is a boobs guy so he came on my and Kaylie’s tits every chance he got.

Did you get titty fucked? Yes, Eric did that.

Are you and Kaylie shaved? I’m completely shaved. Kaylie keeps hers natural because her boyfriend likes it that way. She has a pretty big bush too.

Did you do anal? Yes. Apparently Jon let Eric know that I’m okay with anal so he went straight for my ass.

Did you get the two guys to yourself at any point? Yes. There were a couple of times when Kaylie stepped away for a water break at which point I had both guys.

Did you and Kaylie team up on one of the guys? Yes. If one of the guys finished, both Kaylie and I would team up on the remaining guy while the other recovered.

Will you be hooking up with either of the guys again? The next day, Eric text me wanting to take me on a date. I told him he didn’t have to beat around the bush and that I’d be up for hooking up so we met up the following weekend. Having an new friend with benefits is always a good thing

Would you do it again? Definitely

For the next one, would you want to include a third guy so you can have all 3 holes filled at once? I have thought about that but I think I want to save that experience for my 21st birthday. I need to have some way to top this one..

Are you going to repeat the foursome? Probably not this specific foursome but I would love to have another one at some point.