Me [F] whoring it up in my freshman dorm ... this is [M/F/M] (the actual pt 2) | 2016

Part 1 here. As a quick recap: I was a few months into freshman year, a cute white 5'4” girl who had discovered her inner freak late in high school, and was now casually fucking this really hot 6'2” black guy (Trevor). [And sorry for the confusing title, hadn't initially meant to split this up.]

About a month after our first time, Trevor invited me to a kind of pre-rush event, where a frat he was interested in was having a party downtown and he was supposed to bring a date. Trevor and I had fucked a few more times, but not super regularly, definitely not as often as I had wanted. More frustrating for me, I was pretty annoyed that Trevor had been with other girls, and I actually saw him once making out with another girl at a party we both randomly wound up at. Still, when we fucked, it was freaky, passionate, overwhelming, and really taboo, so I was still down. I loved the challenge of his cock, the huge orgasms, the anal play and dirty talk, and mostly the overall power of his body. Plus it made me feel okay about being with other guys, so the freedom to bang whoever I wanted was pretty nice.

The party was at an art gallery in the city, and it was actually pretty cool, with an open bar, a ton of hot guys and their (somewhat intimidatingly sexy) dates. Trevor had been texting me that we should fool around beforehand, but I had a meeting I had to attend so I was pressed for time and said we should just meet for a cab to take us over. Really though, I liked the anticipation building during the evening and thought that if we started going at it, we might not even make it out.

There was another thing though, I definitely wanted to make him a bit jealous, and make him work for it tonight. I looked really good - a sleek black cocktail dress that worked perfectly on me, and the high heels really showed off my legs. I went a bit heavier on the makeup, still a natural look but a bit darker, making me look a bit less “girl next door” and just sexier. When he stopped by my room to get me, I could tell he was surprised and excited - he had never seen me fully done up before.

At the art gallery, he definitely used me as arm candy, introducing me to all the frat brothers and their dates. He was actually a total gentleman, and was really winning me back over. With the open bar, people started to get pretty drunk by 11pm though, and Trevor got increasingly rambunctious with the brothers, leaving me to chat with some other girls and their dates as well. One of the guys that talked to me the most was an older brother named Dave - I think he was the VP or secretary or something of the frat.

Dave was cute, white, maybe 5'10”, with a perma-stubble beard, in pretty good shape, but very funny and forward. I don't think he brought a date, or if he did she disappeared, because he was just talking to me after a while. We chatted about the usual school bullshit, but as he drank more, he got a bit more handsy and a lot more forward with the conversation. I was a bit taken aback with some of his questions (“how are you enjoying the college hookup culture?”), but a few more drinks and stories from him, and I got into it. At one point, he asked me flat out how I liked fucking Trevor. I laughed and said, “wouldn't you like to know...” I wasn't going to answer, but Dave was fun and I definitely didn't want to push him away. The whole time, we had definitely been getting friendly, and I was touching his arm and biting my lower lip suggestively. I wasn't going to fuck him with Trevor there, but I wanted Dave to want me, and I definitely wanted to fuck him eventually.

At 1am or something, the venue had to close, so people started to leave. A group of us headed back to the frat house, and Trevor grabbed me to jump in a cab with him back to campus. A few more people piled in to the back seat, and I wound up sitting on Trevor's lap. Predictably, I felt him getting hard, and it turned me on a lot. I saw Dave in another car, but honestly, I was perfectly happy to pick that up again another day. Trevor was turning out to be a fun (if forceful) drunk, and I figured he was going to be wild tonight. We'd been getting freakier with every encounter, and I was really curious as to what we'd find ourselves doing next... I was definitely down to try full-on anal with him, or maybe see if we could find our way somewhere public, like a library. He had also brought up things like golden showers and tying me up, and I definitely hadn't said no to either, although a golden shower was new to me and I was kinda on the fence about the concept back then.

When we got to the frat house, Dave was already there, and was eye fucking me hard as I walked in with Trevor. Of the maybe 50 people at the party, 15 or so had found their way back to the house, so it was definitely an after-party mood. Dave offered people drinks from the living room bar in the house, and I stuck to the gin and tonics I'd been nursing (or so I thought) all night. Since the cab ride over, Trevor had started getting really handsy, suddenly paying me a lot more attention. He whispered in my ear that he wanted us to get out of there soon, and I nodded, just saying I wanted to use the bathroom first. Dave was nearby and said it was upstairs... and that he'd show me. So I followed him up (I know, but it seemed reasonable at the time, and I wasn't thinking).

The bathroom situation was... interesting. It was a large house, and I guess this was the communal bathroom. There were a couple of urinals, 3 showers, and 3 stalls, all kinda in a row across from the row of sinks/mirrors. It was somewhat rundown and an old house, but it was all actually pretty clean. It was a bit exciting to use their (men's) bathroom, and thinking back, at that point I was probably more impressed by frats and upperclassmen than I should have been. No one was at the urinals, but one of the stalls was occupied, and as I soon realized, that stall was the only one with a door. I think normally I would have waited for that stall, but I really needed to go, my inhibitions were lowered by all the gin, and I was mostly just really was eager to fuck Trevor, so I told Dave to wait and make sure people gave me privacy.

Dave kept talking to me though, and he made me laugh with some joke, which I drunkenly said was making it hard for me to pee. We both started laughing more, and I saw Dave coming around a bit more into view. I told him he was being a total perv, but we both laughed and then he moved in front of the open stall door so he could clearly see me. We made eye contact and I stopped laughing in shock. But I was too drunk to be shocked for long, and as he watched, I started to pee. He smiled, I guess he was proud that he had crossed this wildly taboo line with a girl he just met, and then he stepped away. After, as I washed my hands, Dave was leaning against one of the sinks and we just moved towards each other to start kissing. I broke away a second later as I saw motion in the door...

I guess Trevor had started feeling threatened by Dave (and appropriately so!) because he had come upstairs, and saw us kissing. His reaction wasn't mean, but he was clearly jealous, and still turned on as the tent in his pants betrayed. Trevor actually smiled after a second, as he confidently asked me, “well, who do you want tonight Amy?” I realized then that I had gotten legitimately drunk, and I just blurted out, “I want you Trevor... and I want Dave too.” We all looked at each other for a second, and then Dave said his room was just around the corner. I walked out of the bathroom and started down the hall, with Dave and Trevor walking behind me, clearly (hopefully) staring at my ass.

Dave says when we're at his room, and I back up against the doorframe, pulling Trevor in to kiss me while also grabbing Dave's hand and squeezing it tightly. Then I breakaway and walk into the room, with Dave following and Trevor closing the door behind. I ask Dave if he has any music, and he puts on some Pandora pop/hiphop station. I can't remember what was playing, but I made both of the boys sit on the bed, while I started gyrating and dancing in the middle of the room. I would close my eyes and run my hands down my hips, then turn away from them and bend over, letting them see my full ass. I think I danced for a while before I stood in front of Dave, turned around, and pointed to the zipper of my dress. He pulled it down, and then I started to slowly pull my now-loose dress over my head.

Now I'm in just a lacy black thong (I wore panties this time), a red bra, and my high heels, I started dancing closer to them, giving them each occasional lap dances and rubbing their cocks through their pants. Finally I looked up at Trevor while stroking the outline of Dave's cock - looking Trevor right in the eyes, I asked, “what's the matter? don't either of you want to fuck me?”

They both looked at me, and then started unbuttoning their shirts, tearing them off, and then standing up to take off their pants. It was almost funny to see them both suddenly doing this at the same time. Soon they were both naked, and Trevor's familiar and impressive cock was at full attention, just inches from my face. Dave had a slightly more average dick, but it was very pretty - perfectly straight, circumcised, and now extremely hard, despite all the drinking.

I grabbed Trevor's cock, and started sucking Dave's. I remember, Dave moaned so loud when my lips engulfed his head that I actually stopped to giggle, and he apologized while grabbing my head and pulling me back in. That turned me on so much, that I just started slobbering and taking his whole cock in my mouth as deep as I could. I kept going for a few second, then turned to Trevor to lick his cock as well while stroking Dave. Then I moved to sit on the bed in between them, and I said, “it's my turn.” I think to drunkenly emphasize the point, I unclipped my bra, letting my two C cup breasts spill out.

Trevor had never actually gone down on me (I know), but Dave quickly knelt in front of me and pulled down my panties while I lifted my ass off the bed. A second later he was kissing the inside of my thighs, working up to my pussy. I moaned in pleasure, then grabbed Trevor, who was standing close by, by the hips to pull him even closer to me so I could suck his cock. Dave was great, somehow appropriately aggressive with my pussy given how drunk we were, licking and sucking on my clit hard. I stopped sucking Trevor for a second, to reposition my hips right on the edge of the bed, and asked him to finger me. Pretty soon he had two fingers rubbing my g spot (pretty well, it felt really really good), and I started moaning that I was going to come. With that, Trevor sped up and I felt Trevor's cock growing in my hand. I totally lost control and my whole body started trembling as I came with Dave's fingers inside me. My orgasm seemed to last forever, and I collapsed backward on the bed.

Trevor soon was on top of me, and I loved feeling his weight pressing down on me. In short order, he was fucking me missionary, and I was moaning in ecstasy. I reached out to Dave, “Dave, I want to taste your cock.” He awkwardly kneeled on the bed next to me, and held up my head to help me swallow his cock. Pretty soon, he wanted more, and straddled my face, pushing Trevor somewhat to the side. I had not expected them to be so comfortable so close to each other, but both were so focused on fucking me, I think they ignored the contact between them.

Soon I was having trouble as Dave was face fucking me pretty aggressively, so I tap him to get off of me, and catch my breath. He falls to my side while Trevor keeps fucking me on top. Without Dave there, Trevor kisses me (apparently unbothered by Dave's cock being right there a second earlier), then kisses down my neck. Then he really starts fucking me hard, and I dig my nails hard into his back to hang on.

Soon he's coming, moaning my name loudly while driving so deep inside me. I can't even begin to describe how good it felt to have his cum inside me, and feel like I was taking all of Trevor's enormous power. I laid there, completely spent, with my one arm falling off of Trevor's back and landing in Dave's lap. Even as Dave collapses on me, I lock eyes with him and I see how horny he's gotten.

“Did you have any idea I was such a slut, Dave?” I asked.

Dave said, “I didn't know, I just kinda hoped.” For some reason that turned me on all over again, and I asked him how he wanted to come. He said whatever I preferred, and since I had been thinking about Trevor fucking me in the ass the last few weeks, I offered that...

“Dave, I want you to take my ass, and come inside me. Do you have condoms and lube?” (Trevor was an exception, other than him I always use condoms). It turns out he had condoms, but no lube, and I realized my ass was have lubed up already with Trevor's cum.

Trevor looked surprised - I think he figured he'd be inside my asshole, since he had spent so much time playing with it. So, I offered him a compromise. “Trevor, while Dave gets his condom on, I'd love for you to loosen me up with a nice rimjob... I really need to feel some of your come and spit in my ass before Dave fucks me.” Trevor paused, but fortunately he was drunk enough that this sounded like a good deal, and I rolled on my stomache, stuck my ass up a bit in the air, and soon Trevor had spread my ass apart and I felt his tongue rimming my asshole, then penetrating further and further.

Dave got back soon, and laid down next to me. I rolled to my side a bit so he could spoon me, and I asked him to be gentle. He was, somewhat, but he was excited too and didn't waste long after his cock had found my asshole. I was a bit surprised to feel his whole cock inside of me just shortly after I had gotten used to his head. But it felt good pretty soon (and this wasn't my first anal in the last few weeks) and the cum worked pretty well as lube.

Trevor had settled on the other side of me, and he was watching my face intently as I grimaced and then moaned in response to Dave's cock. Even drunk, I knew pretty quickly what I wanted. One of the most impressive things about Trevor was how many times he could cum in a row... “Trevor, baby, what are you waiting for?”

That was all he need to move in closer to me, and align his cock with my soaking wet pussy. The feeling of being filled twice as full was just overwhelming, and they told me later how weird it was to be able to feel another cock inside of me. I loved having all of their arms fight to hold me, and feel the overwhelming taboo of two men fucking me at once. My orgasm was absolutely insane - I had already come from Dave's oral, so this orgasm was a bit of a surprise, but it emerged from a lot of unbelievable pressure in my ass and pussy. Given how much these two much bigger guys were manhandling me, I had no freedom to move and the orgasm just engulfed me, making my scream out. The entire house (or block) must have heard me. Dave asked me how it was as I settled down, and I told him “It felt so good to be your slut, and do the dirtiest things with you and Trevor.” That was too much for Dave, and he came immediately.

Trevor pulled out a second later and straddled me, holding me down by my neck and telling me to close my eyes just before his cum landed all over my tits and face. Then he collapsed again, and was passed it literally within a minute.

Dave and I stayed up a bit longer, fooling around a bit more, but soon passed out too at 4am or so. The next morning was only a bit awkward, but we were really hung over and absolutely covered in cum. I went in with Dave for a shower, and as he stepped out after a few minutes, Trevor got in. I did give Trevor a quickie blowjob (it was becoming tradition at that point), and then we staggered home, leaving Dave to explain some loud noises to his brothers ;)

(Trevor and I hung out a few more times, but both kinda moved on after that. Dave and I also fucked from time to time, and he was a total freak, but probably nothing else story-worthy. I follow them on facebook today still, but haven't talked to either in a while. Still, the reason I had to write this up, is this is still my go-to fantasy every time I masturbate. Nothing makes me come like thinking about being pressed between those two guys, and coming so hard while being completely filled.)