The best night (m/f/f) | 2016

Senior year of college I had become good friends with Ellie and Leah.

We had met through my roommate who they went to high school with. He was desperate to hook up with Leah and constantly invited her over. Naturally, she always brought Ellie as well. Both girls were extremely attractive. Any guys dream girl.

I abided by the code and did my best to stay way from Leah but I was always very nice to her. And what can I say, I am always a bit of a flirt so we had our moments. I quickly figured out ol roommate had absolutely no chance at all with her but no need to burst his bubble and create house tension. I hung out in the friend zone while he tried to hook up with her.

However, I am a flirt and Ellie and I hit it off. There was always that tension between us. She and Leah were both gorgeous but a tad different. Both had incredible bodies but the difference was in two areas. Ellie had these sexy eyes. Not the cheap (no I swear I'm not looking at your tits) eyes but really genuine gorgeous eyes you could get lost in. Leah? She had tits that would fit a girl three times her size.

Anyhow, late into the year we are at a bar and I'm dancing with Ellie. I am a good dancer and I can tell I am getting Ellie a tad riled up. She is bumping and grinding far beyond the norm. Still, I'm not feeling brave enough to pull my move so I keep buying her drinks and dancing away. Leah is hanging out nearby in our group and she soon joins in. I'm having a blast dancing away with these two hotties and feeling like a million bucks. Not a bad night.

Remember how my roommate is trying to get with Leah? Well near closing time he invites them both back to our place for an after hours party and they agree to come back. This is actually routine by now. We normally drink into the morning until we all pass out.

So we head back to our place but my roommate passes out almost immediately. Leah and Ellie still want to party so we grab some drinks and turn on some tunes. Immediately, we are back to our dancing in my room. We are jamming along with me in the middle between Leah and Ellie. Nice! I can't recall exactly how it happened but suddenly I found myself making out with Ellie. Then, I get spun around, and I'm making out with Leah. This is incredible! It goes back and forth for a while and my mind is running wild. I am convinced I am about to have my first threesome!

The girls stop at some point and go to the bathroom together. They must be discussing a threesome! I am out of my mind. This is going to happen! To ME!

Finally the girls return and Ellie asks, "Ok, so which one of us do you want to hook up with?"

"Both of you!" I exclaim! Followed by a million complements on how attractive they both are.

"No. Really. which one of us do you want to get with?" Ellie responded coolly.

The back and forth continues for a bit before I realize...Oh. Shit. What is going on? Seriously!? How do I answer this? I insist I want them both equally and we should all do it together! But they both adamantly refuse. Crap. No! So close! I plead my case over and over to no avail. At this point do I just take one and upset the other? I can't do it, so I waffle, stumble, and delay a real answer.

The indecisiveness is getting awkward when Ellie finally proposes a solution. "Why don't you hook up with Leah while I wait? Then I will go next?"

WHAT! I am befuddled. I am clearly not getting the threesome I desired but this is the BEST possible outcome I could image. I again stumble through are few "are you sure"s before they both agree. This is unreal!

A moment after agreeing Ellie sits down on the couch and turns on the TV. Leah then grabs my hand and walks me back to my room. As soon as the door is shut Leah grabs me and we start making out. A few moments later I am laying on my back while she straddles me.

Not long after we are both naked and Leah goes down on me. I am quite drunk at this point but I will never forget this part. She is moaning and rubbing her giant tits up and down my dick while sucking me off. Holy shit! She can give head like a porn star. She is deep throating me, licking my shaft up and down, moaning, just going nuts over blowing me. It is the best blowjob I have ever gotten.

I am about to cum so I grab her and flip her over. I am sucking on her tits and fingering her doing the "come hither" motion. It is driving her insane. She screams out for me to do her so I oblige. I grab a condom and enter her from on top. Again, I am quite tipsy at this point, but I can remember her grasping me and begging me to do her harder and faster. I can remember Leah clinging on to her tits as they bounced wildly from my fucking. I have never done a girl so hard in my life.

Her tits are just wonderful and my mind is made up. I have to come on those amazing breasts. As I feel myself starting to come I pull the condom off. She already knows what I am thinking and shouts out for me to come on her. I unload on her stomach and chest and she loves it. Seconds later she is rubbing it in and playing with my cum.

My head was still spinning from the fantastic sex when she kissed me, rolled off the bed, and said "I'll go get Ellie". I'll be honest I had totally forgotten she was sitting in the other room. I watched as she grabbed her clothes and stepped into the hallway. I can still remember the light from the hall sillhoutting her ridiculous body.

A few second later I hear Leah waking Ellie up in the next room. I am straining to hear the conversation. Hoping and praying she is awake and remembers the agreement! I hear the door to the apartment click and think it is all over but... next thing I look up and see a figure standing in my bedroom doorway. It's Ellie.

Ellie steps into the room and asks "Hi, are you ready for me?". We exchange a bit of small chat, mostly about how my recent (a few mins ago!) sex was with Leah. And moments later we are making out.

Our foreplay routine is similar. Ellie goes down on me but she does not give nearly the great blowjob that Leah did. I go down on her a bit and finger her as well. She also loves the "come hither" motion I do while my fingers are in her. Then things go a little differently.

I get a new condom on and Ellie gets on top of me. She eases down, facing me, and we both enjoy the moment. Ellie begins to bounce up and down on me. She is loving it and I am enjoying the view while caressing her tits and nipples. I had just gotten off with Leah so I have a lot of stamina at this point.

Ellie bounces and bounces and bounces some more. My hands are all over her tight body. She finally grabs my hands and plants them firmly on her ass. I am gripping away while she rides me and then she takes my hand further down her ass. She is pushing my hand deeper, deeper, deeper, until I finally figure out... I think she wants me to play with her ass?

I won't lie this is my first time with ass play and I'm a little nervous. I gently ease a finger up against her ass and she is very receptive. She pushes back hard against my finger and it finally slips in. She starts to moan wildly, bouncing on me with my finger in her ass.

I always keep lube near the bed so I pull my finger out and place a few drops on my finger. Now full of confidence, I place my hand back around slip and a finger into Ellie's ass. This drives her wild. She is driven into a frenzy like state as she bounces on me while I finger her ass. I had already gotten off once, and I was filled with alcohol, so Ellie must have ridden my cock with a finger in her ass for a good 10 minutes before she broke down and started shaking. Her enthusiastic moans and contracting pussy made me cum soon after. She confirmed later I had given her the best orgasm of her life.

Ellie slept over and we had a quickie in the morning before she left. I had sex with her and Leah both a few times again before we graduated but I never got my coveted threesome. It was too bad but the sex was always great and I'll never forget the night I had them both back to back.