[m/f/f] [m] Failed Threesome (edited and revised an earlier post) | 2016

So my girlfriend and I go to a gay bar in our city. I'm straight and she's bi though it’s got nothing do with picking up people. Its a nice dive where we can get drunk and avoid hipsters.. Four months ago we went out drinking on a saturday night. My girl is slender, dark brown hair, with blue eyes. Nice breasts, the kind you can get a firm grip on but not too large and a fantastic ass. (we're both in our mid 20's)

We grabbed a drink or two and ran into this girl we will call S. Now S was this shortener lesbian girl, a little plump but attractive. Short black hair, big chest, annoying laugh. We hung out and chatted very casually, mostly S rambled about how much she worked, her psychotic roommates. She had just gotten out of a relationship. Generally fun. It crossed my mind she was interested in A (what we'll call my girl) but I had no complaints.

S said she was going to another bar to catch a show and meet up with one of her friends, this older dude she said was cool. She was gonna catch a taxi and asked if we wanted to go. We agreed and offered to drive her. Met her friend, did some shots, a few beers and an hour passed. It’s a two floor bar, the club is down in the basement. Dark, small, black painted walls, and smells like mildew. S kept pulling my girl away and dancing with her, pretty innocent besides her “I want to fuck you eyes”. I saw what was happening and just kept my distance, watched the band. We went upstairs to grab a smoke and so they could use the restroom. When A came out she walked over and said, “I think she wants me,” I just smiled and gave a slight shrug.

When we made it back down, their dancing became more intense as they beganmaking out. Mind you there were about 20 people in the room who were watching. S's friend was still there. They pulled me over to the corner of the bar and S ground her ass against my cock while my girl kissed me. S asked “Are you sure you don’t mind me wanting you’re girl?” as she gyrated her hips. I went to get us another round before we left. The bartender smiled and said “You're a lucky man these are on the house”.

Now we made our move to leave but S was a bit hesitant. She was down to go back to our place but insisted her friend (call him E) was there. See E was this sort of scuzzy looking dude, beard tattoos, like a Hell’s Angel’s reject. From the previous conversation it seemed he only partied and sold weed. We were whiskey soaked so finally we said fuck it.

When we made it back, we were out of everything but gin. Not even mixers, I poured four coffee cups of it. I put some music on and E and I chatted as S pulled my girl A into the bedroom. E and I sorta hung out in the living room for a few, awkwardly. Just shooting the shit and listening to a couple tunes. He said he had coke on him, that S asked him to get in exchange for possibly hooking up. Went on rambling about how she hadn’t had a man in 9 years and how tight that pussy had to be. (his words not mine)I told him we'd be down and he laid out four lines on the stove. E and I blew ours and then the girls stumbled out naked. S sorta paraded herself, both of her nipples were pierced, while my girl was a little more shy about it. (we both used to do drugs but only once in a great while do now if they're offered) Still she didn’t try to cover up as E and i watched the two of them bend over to do their lines. S pulled my girl over to the couch were she started kissing and fingering her. E and I watched, fully clothed, as S worked her fingers into my gf's pussy. Now the only problem I had with this was that I didn't trust him, he was hospitable and didn’t actively try to cross boundaries but still not someone I’d leave alone in my apartment.

After putting on the show S pulled A into the shower. My girl doesn't shave her pussy, which is fine by me, E knocked on the door and told them he was opening it. After the door was opened S threw the shower curtain open. My girl had her back stretched against the wall as S was shaved her. S pulls my girl out of the shower as she stuck out her chest. A followed her out. E ran his hands over this girls breasts as she smiled and made eyes and I did the same. For a few minutes he and I took turns feeling up the two girls. A stuck her chest out a bit during this, not so much as S’s whole exhibitionist thing but more saying, “I want to be touched”.

After this went on, the girls made there way into the bedroom, taking turns going down on each other. It was very late by now, and becoming clear S wasn’t gonna have any part in fucking E. I feel bad for him but he got used for the coke. (he made it clear it wasn’t something he was into, only picked it up for this girl). It took convincing but he realized he wasn't gonna get to fuck S and that i didn’t want him staying there.

Finally I was able to drive him home, he thanked me for letting him watch and rambled about my girlfriend's clit. When I got back it had to bet 5am. A and S had been fucking the whole time (about a 2-3 hour span) S being a "lesbian" (she isn’t anymore) wasn't much into with me. The lights were off, both A and I groped and sucked on S’s tits, I worked her clit for a while. My girl flipped over and I started fucking her from behind. S passed out at this point. Understandably I wasn't thrilled. I’d wanted a threesome or at least watching the girls without complication. After she came I pulled out and began stroking my cock and made a move to cum on S's ass. My girl put her hand out and blocked some of my jizz. I took some of the cum off her hand and wiped it over S’s ass.