Worried one of use was going to be left out (MFF) | 2016

This story takes place with my [19M] college girlfriend Jess [18F] some years back. We had both been virgins before we started dating and had recently started having sex. We were basically trying anything new we could think of in the bedroom.

Jess is hot. She's pretty average height (5'4") with slender legs, a nice butt that was always a pleasure to grab a handful of, and perky 32C breasts.

This particular evening we were at a house party nearby my apartment on a Friday night. We were feeling a little isolated at the party and hadn't really been drinking. Jess had stepped outside for a minute with a friend and when she came up to me she leaned in and said: "I want you to pick up a girl at this party to bring home for the both of us." Hottest. Moment. Ever. "Make sure she's hot."

I take a moment to collect my thoughts and scan the room for a girl who might be down for what I am about to propose. Neither Jess or I knew anyone at this party, so getting shot down here wouldn't haunt me, but not giving this effort 110% would, so I pick a girl and walk up.

I found myself talking to a cute girl with strawberry blonde hair. She was about 5'2" with a petite frame, slender hips and smallish breasts. She capped it all off with a goofy smile that could turn sly in a heartbeat, which is what happened in a moment after I said: "Do you see that girl in the corner there?" "Yeah, she's cute" "I want you to go over there and make out with her" "What really?" "Well say hi and tell her your name first" "...All right. By the way, my name is Tara."

As Tara walked over to Jess I took a moment to appreciate what a tight little ass she had. Jess was a little taller than Tara (5'4") and was wearing some big heels (she was a little self-conscious next me since I'm 6', with broad muscular shoulders) so she stood a bit over Tara. I was nervous when Jess looks over at me with a nervous and confused expression when Tara moves in for a kiss.

Jess didn't take much convincing. She came back at Tara with a passionate kiss and gently caressed her face and pulled her in close by her neck. Jess looks right at me as they are kissing and slowly reached down and grabs Tara's tight butt. Jess pulled Tara into her body as they continued to kiss with a passion that was quickly turning to lust.

Maybe I should have been embarrassed that my mouth was just hanging open, but nobody there noticed. As I regained my composure, I saw every guy in the room was staring at them, and every girl was looking flustered that they were so abruptly ignored. I decided this spectacle had gone as far as it needed to here and grabbed the girl's coats.

They were a little disappointed when I stopped them to go back to my apartment. I really think they were ready to fuck right there in the corner. We only had to walk a couple blocks back to my place, but it took forever because the girls kept going at each other. Eventually we make it up to my place, past my stunned roommates, and into my room.

The girls were constantly grabbing at each other and kissing, groping, and biting each other every step home. They were on the bed before I even closed the door behind us. I watched for a moment not particularly concerned if I was going to get in on this or just watch.

Things were getting hotter as Jess slipped her hand up Tara's shirt and moved her bra out of the way. Tara let out a pleased 'mmmh' and grabbed Jess's breast and leaned in to kiss it through her clothes. Tara decided that wasn't working for her and slipped off Jess's shirt and bra in some manner of voodoo manuver that I didn't grasp. Freshly topless Jess got on top of Tara as they were grinding against each other and slid her hand slowly to Tara's waist, then under her belt, further down her pants, until finally I could see that she had started to rub Tara's clit.

Tara moaned loudly at this development. She began to rise her hips up and down and began arching her back. Everything was building when suddenly she let out a little gasp, took a sharp breath in and moaned loudly. Jess leaned in to kiss Tara and remove her hand from her new friend's pants. After a moment Tara sat up and said: "Excuse me while I go get myself ready for the main event" as she looked at me. Jess let Tara up and Tara headed to the bathroom through an apartment that appeared to have been vacated by my roommates.

As soon as I heard the bathroom door close, Jess blurts out:"I don't think I can do this." Stunned, I replied "Really? because I think you just did! Tara wasn't exactly complaining when she stepped out." "That's not what I mean. I can do you, and I can do her, but I can't bear for you to do her." Crestfallen, I asked, "what? why? was there something wrong?" Jess looked embarrassed as she replied "It's just... Tara's pussy is so smooth, and perfect, and hairless. I got really turned on when I was reaching down her pants and got all the way to her clit without finding a single hair, I couldn't help but to finger her, but now I'm embarrassed -- I don't even trim my bush and I don't want her to see me and judge me for being dirty, and her pussy is so tight I don't want you to fuck her and liker her more than me." In wisdom that exceeded my years, I accepted that there were boundaries here that Jess would not want us to cross. We quickly discussed what to tell Tara and how to proceed.

Tara came back into the room with a big grin on her face. She was disappointed when I told her what Jess and I had discussed. As we were explaining the 'rules' (basically Tara and I couldn't touch or even kiss) that Jess and I had come up with, she moved over to sit next to Jess (who was still topless) on the edge of the bed. She starts kissing Jess's neck and whispers something into her ear. Jess nods enthusiastically, looks at me and says "Why aren't you over here, come stand right here!"

I walk over to them and Jess unzips my pants and pulls out my cock. Jess looks me in the eye and pulls Tara in for a kiss while she begins to stroke my cock. She gets about two pumps in before she pushes Tara away and shoves my cock into Tara's mouth (see why I kept calling them 'rules'?). Tara enthusiastically bobs up and down on my member and immediately begins the sloppiest BJ I had received. While Tara was getting to work Jess took off her pants and strategically hid her granny panties. Jess come back to us and says "That's good, but I think I can do better" Tara lets off of my cock and Jess immediately deep throats all of my 7" down to the balls. If there is a heaven, I was in it at that moment.

Tara caresses Jess's breasts and kisses her on her neck while I'm getting the BJ dreams are made of. Tara's hand begins to wander down to Jess's wonder garden, when Jess abruptly leans back, pulls me with her knocking me into Tara, who at some point had gotten naked.

Seeing that I was the only one with clothes on, I quickly scramble out of my clothes. Finally naked, I see Jess laying on her back with her legs spread and Tara making a move to get some dinner at the Y. Jess pushed Tara away and said "No! It's time for cock!" She looks at me and says "get in here!"

Not one to disappoint a lady, I climb over the bed with all the grace of a drunk monkey and dive my cock deep into Jess' pussy. Normally this would be a problem as Jess was always super tight and had to be eased into taking my whole cock into her, but tonight was different. I could feel her pussy was hungry for cock and nothing else would satisfy her. I found this so hot that I wasn't really paying attention to what Tara was doing and just started to fuck Jess as hard as I ever desired. Soon I could feel Jess's pussy throbbing around my cock as she was rising to meet my every thrust.

Jess had never cum during sex before (we had to get her off by other means) and I was genuinely surprised that it was about to happen. I looked around again and saw that Tara was laying next to us, head thrown back in ecstasy while Jess fingered her pussy to match my movements. Tara's face was flush and she began moaning louder and louder, arched her back and cried out while she experienced another orgasm. I felt Jess's pussy get tighter and hotter as she followed Tara and moaned, gasped, and finally let out a little whimper and released as she had her own orgasm. I slowed down my pace to admire the girls in their bliss.

As Jess came down from her orgasm, I saw a realization flash on her face. She shot up, looked down, and asked "where's the condom?" In my being a horny 19-year-old with 2 girls in a hurry to get fucked, I hadn't even thought about a condom, but it was the only birth control that Jess and I used. Jess slid me out of her and asked "did you cum?"

"N-no," I replied (this is true and remains the great mystery in this story) "I was just about there, but held back to enjoy the show." Jess was visibly angry at this, but Tara had other ideas.

"Oh you poor guy, it's definitely your turn now" Tara said as she leaned down and took my cock once again into her mouth. Jess still looked angry, but she set that aside to join Tara at my cock and began playing with my balls. I was too close to ecstasy to be worried about reprisals. I felt myself building to a monster orgasm of my own, having ridden a wave of sexual euphoria for most of the evening. Jess saw the signs and just before the pivotal moment, she took me away from Tara's mouth and into her own.

Apparently Tara wasn't happy with this change. She protested "that's no fair! I worked hard, I want his cum too!" Just hearing her say that and thinking that these girls are literally fighting over my cum made me want to bust right there. I let out a loud moan, leaned my head back felt the orgasm begin. Jess stopped just as I started to shoot and pulled my cock to the side while she kept stroking it. A couple pulses later she took me back in her mouth where I kept cumming for what felt like a week. As I finished I looked down to see that Jess had aimed me right into Tara's face, and then took me back into her mouth to finish. Tara had cum dangling over her nose, in her eyebrow, and unfortunately a bit in her eye.

Jess wiped her chin and swallowed with a smile on her face.