My threesome with my gf and her cousin (m/f/f) part 2 | 2016

The first part of the story is here.

First of all, thanks for all the upvotes. I wasn't sure how well this story would be received. If your wondering about the taboo nature of our encounters, it did eventually become an issue, mostly with Amy (my gf). By 'eventually' I mean after a year or so - we definitely had a lot of fun together before it started to get weird. Sam was more into it than Amy without a doubt, but I really think that we all kind of brought out the kink in each other during this time.

Things were different with me and Sam now. She was a lot more touchy-feely, smiley and flirty. I think it made Amy jealous. You might have noticed in our last threesome I actually didn't have sex with Amy (I would have, but you try lasting in that situation!), so I think that touched a nerve. Still, on the outside we were all having fun together, and at the time I didn't really notice anything amiss. Besides, I really wanted to do it again (obviously).

It was quite awhile before we had another chance to do something like this. Like I mentioned, Sam was only in town once every couple months or so, and we wouldn't necessarily have a lot of time with just the three of us. She still had the same boyfriend too.

She came into town once and we were hanging out at my place this time. Definitely a lot riskier there as I didn't have the privacy of a basement, just a room with my entire family on the same floor. We smoked some weed at a favourite spot of mine down the street (couldn't smoke indoors at my place), then walked back to my house. It was during the day. We get to my place and we go up to my room, the only place where there was really any privacy. All I had was a bed and a desk, so we all sat on the bed. It didn't take long before Sam initiated things. She started stroking my cock outside my pants, and asked me how I like to kiss Amy. So I showed her, and we started making out while Sam continued touching me. I put my hand down Amy's pants and started playing with her pussy, then started fingering her. She was a little timid at first but she was getting into it now, her pussy was getting very wet. Then I turn and started kissing Sam. It was a lot more sensual this time, not the crazy animal make-out that we had last time. It was really sexy, and I couldn't help but put my hand down her pants. Just like last time, she was fucking dripping wet, like holy shit I didn't even know a girl could get so wet. She obviously was really turned on by the whole thing, I could tell she was already down to fuck. It seemed like Amy started to feel a little left out, so I did what any gentleman would do - I started fingering them both. We were all laying down on our backs, me in the middle, with one hand down each of their unzipped pants, fingering each of their wet pussies. I'd kiss one, then turn my head and kiss the other. It was amazing. Until my little brother knocked on the door. He practically walked in on us! To this day I don't know what he saw or remembers, but if he came in 10min later he would have seen some shit. Anyway he was telling us it was dinnertime or something, I don't remember, I just remember the blue balls.

Fast forward to the next day (I think), we were back at Amy's basement. The usual smoking and hanging out. We started talking about kinky stuff that we liked. I think the last encounter sort of opened the floodgates, because Amy was getting way more kinky now. She liked to be tied up, have her hair pulled, get spanked, even chocked a little bit. She started a small collection of sex toys. She had handcuffs, a leather choker, some small chains and stuff, a small whip. Probably sounds more hardcore than it really was, remember we were all still young. So naturally all of this came up in our conversation. Sam was very interested in all of this, and I enjoyed describing to her in detail how I fucked her cousin. So, after awhile of this kinky talk and getting high, Sam (with puppy dog eyes and the cutest voice) said to me, "Dave, I want to see you fuck Amy." I look over at Amy and asks what she thinks. She says, "Ok, but I want you guys to tie me up first."

We pulled out all the stops. Had her on all fours with her ass sticking up. Got the choker on her with the chains hooked up to it, had the handcuffs on her, everything. Once she was all setup her pussy was already glistening as I started lightly hitting her ass with the whip. Sam helped me get everything on her, and even took a picture once it was all done (before you ask, I don't have it). So after I spanked her for awhile I looked at Sam, who was right next to me, and said "So you want to see me fuck her now?" I could tell she was really turned on, and I was already rock hard, so when she said "yes" I immediately went to town. I fucked Amy harder than I had ever fucked her, it was almost like I wanted to show off for Sam. Her face was right next to my cock going in and out of her cousins wet pussy as Amy moaned in pleasure. Sam looked up at me with those wanting eyes, and I grabbed her hair and started making out with her as I continued to fuck Amy. She pulled on her cousins hair while I fucked her, then spanked her ass as I pulled on the chains for leverage. Amy was practically screaming, I could tell she loved being the centre of attention. At one point I pulled my cock out and Sam sucked on it, tasting her cousins pussy juice. She was a really aggressive cocksucker, pushing it down as far as she could, a lot different than what I was used to. It was too good, I didn't want to cum just yet. So I stuck it back in and made out with her while still pulling on Amy's chains, choking her a bit while I used the leverage to fuck her as deep and hard as I could. After a few more minutes of this I was ready to cum, so I grabbed Sam by the hair and put her head down right on Amy's ass as I pulled out. I shot my load all over her ass, and Sam was right there licking it up as soon as it came out. She cleaned my cock a bit, as Amy turned around and gave it a few licks as well. Then they kissed lightly, and Sam turned to me and said "That was so fucking hot." And it was.

Shortly after this Sam had to go back home. It was sad, especially since I didn't actually get to fuck her this time. Me and Amy did a lot more kinky stuff together, including anal for the first time. Side note - I'll never forget the time she was riding my cock (on my moms bed no less), and just as I said I was about the cum she pulls it out and stuck it right in her ass as she was coming back down. Holy fuck that was amazing, even now years later no one has done anything like that to me again.

So, after awhile Amy hits me with the big surprise. Sam is coming into town, this time for the whole summer! Needless to say, I was pretty fucking pumped. Guess I'll have to save that for part 3.