My First Post: Had a devil's threeway with a girl who resembled Moaning Myrtle (no pun intended) [M/F/M] | 2016

I got off work and read an e-mail from a guy I had been chatting with about teaming up to double team wanting women. We had never actually spoke, and the only clue I had to what he looked was a fuzzy, sunglass adorned, "ice-man" look-alike, only less angular.

He had posted an ad on CL and received a few responses. We were hoping to meet up with a girl who had spent the day partying in a sea of red and white drunken masses. A young, wild, college girl wanting to go crazy with two guys. To hedge our bets, he posted another ad and got another response. She wanted us there, like, now. After picking up a pack of condoms (only) at the local grocery mega-mart, I drove to the address he had forwarded to me. I parked and got out of my car, walking down the street in the brisk city night. I saw the outline of his shadow halfway down the block and assumed correctly that this was my correspondent.

A was decently good-looking but after only exchanging a few words, I knew his prowess came from his tone, demeanor, and general confidence.

We both stood outside, covering our story with our hands in our pockets, trying to keep warm. We were waiting for her response to our arrival for what seemed like eternity. Was this really gonna happen? I knew virtually nothing about this girl except that she answered a CL ad and had two complete strangers standing on the stoop to her apartment. After about five minutes the heavy fog turned into light sprinkles and my doubts were starting to sink in. Then, seemingly out of nowhere, he straightened his posture and started to walk towards my direction. I turned around and saw her.

M was a cute little thing. Standing around 5'4 and wearing a black dress with a big, black, windbreaker jacket over it, zippered up to the neck. She had short black hair, cut in a bob, and black-framed rectangular glasses. I could've swore she was in Harry Potter. I couldn't believe that I was about to have a devil's threeway with two complete strangers. One of whom looked like a hot, more mature version of Moaning Myrtle.

I had brought a selection of ciders with me and we poured ourselves a few glasses while we sat on her couch chatting. She was nervous. Everything about her posture, her laughter, and uncertain eye contact screamed that she couldn't believe the situation either. She was very friendly and warm aside from the nervousness and confessed to us that she had never had a threesome before and was excited for her first time. M looked to be in her late thirties or early forties but could easily have passed for 26. She finally relaxed and took off her jacket to reveal the res of her dress. A square cut top with little ribbons and button things. At this point, I wasn't too concerned with her fashion choices. She had a cute little rack and showed a "good girl" amount of cleavage. She was starting to relax, her body was becoming loose. I had been casually resting my hand so that my fingers touched her thigh near the hem of her dress, which was just about mid-thigh sitting down.

Then my friend, sitting to her left, finally broke the tension and started kissing her, deeply. I took this opportunity to run my hand up her leg, which she eagerly uncrossed. We both had our hands all over her as she sat between us. I started kissing her neck, her chest, as she and A continued to make out. She stopped and turned abruptly and started to kiss me. She had very soft lips and had near-perfect technique. I got lost for a moment and let the feeling of her passionate kiss take over. I reached my arms around her and unhooked her bra (expertly I might add ;)) and this unleashed another wave of intense fury. We were both kissing her and simultaneously running both hands over every inch of her exposed body. She spread her legs for us and I started to explore over her panties. I couldn't stand it anymore so I got down to the ground and spread her legs wide open, pushing the hem of her slip back. Her pussy was spilling over the sides of her panties so I kissed up her thigh to the crease of her leg and ran my tongue up and down the lining of her panties, grazing the outer most parts of her lips. After more teasing, and realizing that A was taking his pants off, I slid her panties off and kissed and licked her pussy in short, shallow, strokes. I looked up just as I heard A say "Holy Fuck." She had wrapped her small hands around the base of A's thick cock and was slowly rocking her head back and forth as her lips wrapped tightly around his throbbing shaft.

It was so hot watching her suck his cock and hearing him praising her talents. I started licking her pussy with more fervor, sucking her clit into my mouth, running circles around it with the tip of my tongue, and then trapping it between the stud of my piercing and the tip of my tongue, vibrating it up and down. I could hear her cock-stifled moans getting louder and more enthusiastic. A then asked if I wanted to trade and see how good she was. I was up and stripping in seconds. I was still wearing my shirt and socks when she took me into her mouth. A was right. She was amazing. The same soft lips I experienced moments ago kissing mine, were now gently wrapped around my growing hard on. In less than a minute she had me so hard, it looked like my cock just might explode, literally. Every vein looked like it was at full capacity and I could feel her velvet-like tongue circling the engorged head of my cock. She was absolutely incredible. I've had great bj's before. You could tell that she actually really enjoyed giving head, but in a classy, upscale kind a way. There was a certain sophistication and understanding in the way she conformed her mouth to my cock.

After a little more time, A suggested we fuck her, and she was amenable to that. He bent her over on the couch while I sat in front of her. He spread her cheeks open, and slid his cock inside of her, almost effortlessly after we had both spent a considerable amount of time licking her pussy. She took me into her mouth and I reached under her, pinching her nipples and he slammed his cock into her. She was rocking back and fourth so much, it was hard to keep my cock in her mouth. A fucked her hard for the next few minutes before asking me if I wanted a shot. He pulled out of her and I told her to straddle me. She quickly spread her legs over my lap and I could feel her reach her hand around my cock and slip it inside her pussy. She felt incredible. I got so hard knowing my cock was so deep inside her after she had just taken another moments before.

She rode me on her red sofa until A suggested we move to the bedroom. On the way down the hall I asked her if she wanted to be fucked in the ass. She gave a coy yet enthusiastic "Yes!"

A laid down on the bed and M got on top of him, they fucked while I changed condoms and started to prepare her ass for my cock. I spit on her ass hole and lubed my index finger good. As I pressed my finger against her ass, it suddenly slipped in and she let out a little moan. I could tell from how easy it was for my finger to penetrate her that she was already eager to get dp'd. A closed his legs and I straddled them as I grabbed my cock and pressed my throbbing head against the opening of her ass. I pressed my hips into her more and with a sudden pop, the head of my cock disappeared inside of her and I readjusted to start fucking her. Once we were both securely inside her, we started to really pick up momentum. I was grabbing her hips and burying my cock deep into her ass while he was underneath her, rhythmically and deliberately sliding his cock in and out of her pussy. I could feel how tight she was with both of us inside of her and could feel the head of his cock every time we passed each other through the thin wall separating her holes.

I asked her how much she loved feeling both of us inside her, filling her up, and stretching her holes. How much she enjoyed feeling two hard, throbbing cocks thrusting deep inside her. It was all she could do to muster up a "yes" and "I love it" between gasps and moans.

I started to fuck her harder, which triggered A to cum while he was still deep inside her. He got out from under her and I continued fucking her ass like there was no tomorrow. She was absolutely loving it. And for a girl who had never had a threesome before, she was taking it very well. I pulled out of her ass and flipped her on her back after A exited to clean up. I changed condoms before climbing on top of her and shoving my cock deep into her pussy. I was face to face with her and loved the way her pussy felt. Since I had just been fucking her ass, I (my cock) was noticing the tactile differences and soon, I was whispering into her ear that I was going to cum. She urged me to cum and I told her I was going to cum inside her, asking her if she was ready to have two men cum inside her back to back. She told me "Yes, cum, please" and with that, I exploded inside her, pushing my cock in her pussy as far as it could go as it pulsed, shooting cum into the tip of the condom.

I pulled out of her after I had expelled my last drop of cum and immediately started to tongue her pussy. I slid my finger inside her, stroking the ceiling of her pussy as I sucked and licked her clit like it was the best thing I had ever tasted. A came back into the room and started to suck and bite her nipples. Her moans escalated and I could feel her body start to vibrate. In moments I could feel her pussy contracting around my finger, my tongue still rolling circles around her clit. Her body was seizing and a flurry of "oh my god's" came uncontrollably from her mouth.

I looked up at her, glasses fogged and askew, hair mussed and frizzed, and saw the most genuine look of happy satisfaction I've seen. You could see the sense of accomplishment and fulfillment in her euphoric gaze. She laughed and thanked us repeatedly, running her hands through our hair as we kissed her body on either side of her.

It felt good knowing that we were able to make her first threesome experience that exciting and pleasurable. We decided we should all make this a regular Saturday night thing, and I can't wait to see the possibilities on where it could lead.

tl;dr - I met up with two strangers I had met on craigslist. The female had striking similarities to Moaning Myrtle from Harry Potter and we dp'd her and came inside her while wearing condoms.