(MM)y first threeso(m)e | 2016

Apologies if you've already read this story. I posted it a while back, only to remove it again. But as I recently had another encounter with Greg and Peter, I figured I should repost the story of how it all begun :)

I'm a mostly straight, bi guy, in my mid-twenties. I've mostly had experience with women, but I've had a couple of gay encounters that I've really enjoyed, and for a long time I've fantasized about having sex with two men at the same time.

So when I met this gay couple online who were looking for a third man to join them, I got interested. We emailed back and forth a couple of times, and determined that we were looking for the same thing - they were looking for someone to share, and I was looking for a couple to fuck me and tell me what to do.

After a couple of emails, we decided to meet up, so one cold November evening, I was standing in front of their house, about to have my first threesome (of any kind) with two men I hadn't met. I was nervous but excited as I walked up to the door and rang the door bell.

After a few seconds, a man in his mid-forties opened the door, who I recognized as Peter from our online conversation.

"Hi", I said awkwardly.

"Welcome. Please, come in", said Peter.

I entered the hallway, and Peter closed the door behind me as I took off my shoes. Another man came out into the hallway from the room at the end. That must be Greg, who I hadn't seen before. He was a bit older than Peter, probably in his late 40's, but in good shape.

Greg came up to me, and as we'd agreed, immediately grabbed hold of my neck and said:

"Come with me."

He pulled me by my neck along the hallway, and into the room at the end, which turned out to be the master bedroom.

"Start stripping" Greg told me, as Peter joined us in the bedroom.

I took off my jacket and shirt, and as I pulled down my jeans, Greg pushed me on my chest back on the bed. He got up on the bed and straddling my chest.

"Take out my cock."

While I fumbled with Greg's jeans, I felt Peter pull off my jeans, socks and underwear. As my erect penis sprang loose from my underwear, Peter laughed and said "Looks like he likes it."

I finally got Greg's pants open and pulled out his semi-hard cock. He pushed my face towards it and I opened my mouth to take it in. As he started moving in and out of my mouth, I could feel his member growing harder and harder until he was fully erect. He wasn't that big, probably about five inches, which was fine with me.

Peter meanwhile got undressed, and positioned himself next to us on the bed.

After a couple of minutes of Greg fucking my face, while Peter was sitting next to us on the bed stroking himself, Greg got off my chest and let Peter take my head in his hand and guide my mouth to his cock. Peter was already erect, with a member that was slightly longer than Greg's and substantially thicker.

I took Peter's cock head in my mouth, and started licking it around the edges, down along the shaft, down to his balls the balls, taking one after the other into my mouth. Peter moaned as I played with his balls in my mouth, before I gradually worked my way back up his cock, and took his whole cock into my mouth and started sucking him properly.

In the background, I was aware of Greg rummaging around in the bedside cabinet, but I was focused on the way Peter's cock felt in my mouth, so it wasn't until I felt Greg's hands on my back that I took notice.

Greg directed me to lie on my back in the middle of the bed. As I continued to suck Peter's cock, I felt a cold dab of lube on my asshole as Greg started to gradually work his finger in through my sphincter. He was gentle, trying to work his way in without hurting me, which made me relax and open up to him. After a while, he added another finger, and then another, gradually opening up my asshole.

While Greg was finger fucking my ass, I continued sucking Peter's cock. After a few minutes of warmup action, and after a bit more lube, Greg decided I was ready.

He took out a condom, and asked Peter:

"You want to go first or second?

"Sure, I'll go first."

Peter pulled his cock out of my mouth, took the condom from Greg, and started to put it on.

"Get on your knees, and start sucking me", Greg told me.

I got up on my hands and knees, with my ass facing Peter, and again wrapped my mouth around Greg's member. Like last time, he put his hand on the back of my head, and started fucking my mouth. Behind me, knowing that Greg had already loosened me up, Peter lost no time in pushing his cock into my ass. Though his cock wasn't especially big, it felt thick and hot as he pushed it deep into me, and started moving in and out.

Peter and Greg started fucking me, each on one end, both pushing into me at the same time. They kept to a fairly slow pace, but despite that, a couple of times Peter pushed me so far forward into Greg's cock that it made my eyes water. Thankfully, they would stop for a few second while I recovered, before they started fucking me again. From time to time, Peter would grab hold of my erect cock as he pushed into me.

After a couple of minutes of them fucking me between them, Peter suddenly said "I'm going to come."

He pulled out of me, took off his condom, and ejaculated over my back. I could feel the hot drops of cum spread all over my back, as Greg held my head steady on his cock.

After Peter was done, Greg told me to get on my back facing him. He quickly put on a condom, positioned his cock, and in one stroke buried his cock in my ass.

Either because he had a different technique than Peter, or because he felt he could go all out as I wasn't being spit roasted this time, Greg wasn't as gentle as Peter, but immediately started pistoning in and out of my ass. He quickly got into a regular rythm, fucking me with long strokes and clearly enjoying the sensation of my asshole around his cock. I wasn't sure how long he could go on like this, but after Peter's fucking, and now Greg's powerful strokes, my ass started protesting that it would be more than a little sore tomorrow.

After a couple of minutes of fucking, Greg pulled out of me, and asked:

"Where do you want it?"

"On my face", I immediately responded, as I'd always wanted the sensation of getting a face full of cum.

Greg took off his condom and moved to sit on my chest. He stroked his cock a few time, and as I closed my eyes, I felt a load of thick cum splatted over my face and chest.

Greg took his time, making sure that he'd got all the cum out and onto me, rubbing his cock over my mouth to get the last bit of cum out. "I want you to come now", said Greg, still sitting on my chest, with his cock in his hand and Peter sitting in the bed next to us. My cock had stood at full attention since I walked into the bedroom, so it only took me a minute of stroking myself before I exploded, with my cum covering my stomach. We stayed like that for a while, before Greg got off my chest.

Peter handed me a towel, and I wiped Greg's cum out of my face, and removed my own cum from my stomach and crotch, before wiping the lube around my ass.

Then I got dressed, and Greg walked me to the front door. We said goodbye, and I walked down the stairs and away from their house, with my ass reminding me of the pounding I'd taken every step I took.