[M] Threesome goes a little (a lot) different than expected [M/M/F] >> [M/M] | 2016

Okay, so originally I posted a really brief and rushed version of this story in r/sex. Someone commented that the folks over here might like to hear it, so here I am, with something that's written out a bit better! (Warning that this is pretty ridiculously detailed. I remember it really vividly, and tried to get across how I was feeling at the time)

So a week or so ago, I got involved in a threesome with a domme named Lys and another (sub/switch) dude named Matt. I identify as straight, as did Matt and Lys. So, after several days of talking to them via email, we set the date and the location (Lys's house). Lys set down the rules as soon as I got there: she wanted Matt and I to fuck her at the same time, the only stipulations being that we couldn't come inside of her and that we had to lick up our own come afterwards. Nothing I hadn't done before, and Lys was a pretty chill domme, so I wasn't really worried.

Foreplay was a lot of groping and kissing, Matt and I took turns eating Lys out and Lys used her hands/feet (depending on who was where) to get us hard. When Lys decided it was time, she pushed Matt onto his back and climbed on top of him, beckoning me from behind. It ended up with her riding Matt and me taking her from behind. It was pretty damn great, the angle and tightness feeling absolutely amazing on me. Soon enough, I was getting close, so I pulled out and came. I was expecting to have to eat Lys out again or rim her or something to clean up the come, but I didn't aim too well and got it all over Matt's balls. Lys just laughed and hopped off of Matt, sitting back and telling me to get to work. Not exactly the direction I thought the evening would have gone, but okay.

I kneel down and start licking at Matt, a little nervous considering I had never done anything like that before. I felt kinda bad that I made Lys hop off of him mid-stroke, so I started working his cock over with my hands in an attempt to keep him hard. I got pretty into it, and Lys ordered me to suck his cock, so I ended up giving him a sloppy first-time-I've-ever-done-this blowjob, which he seemed to enjoy. Honestly, it was so fucking hot. Being able to get him moaning under my touch was pretty fucking erotic and I could feel myself getting hard again as I sucked him off, sexual orientation notwithstanding. He, in the heat of the moment, moaned out something to the effect of, "God, I want to fuck your tight ass." and I, in the heat of the moment, looked up and said, "Do it."

He pulled me off his cock by my hair. Lys seemed a little surprised, but nodded her approval when we paused for a second to look in her direction. Permission granted, I reached for the bottle of lube we had used earlier with Lys. I didn't know too much about how sex between two guys worked, but I knew it'd hurt like a bitch if I didn't lube up and stretch myself open. I spread some lube on my fingers and worked them into my ass, watching Lys grab a vibrator and use it on herself while making out with Matt. It briefly flashed through my mind that I was straight and had never wanted to fuck a man, but my cock begged to differ and I was so unbelievably turned on and goddammit, Matt was hot.

I probably spent more time than most people trying to stretch myself open, the ever-diminishing rational side of my brain reminding me that I had never done this and if fingers were uncomfortable, it would hurt like a bitch when Matt fucked me. When I finally figured I was ready, I laid down on my back on the bed next to Lys, who propped a pillow up under my ass while Matt rolled on a condom and pushed my legs apart. It was pretty nerve-wracking, waiting for him to put it in. He ran his fingers through my hair and grunted out a "You ready?", to which I nodded and he slowly pressed his cock inside of me.

It hurt. I'm not gonna lie, it hurt like hell. I screwed my eyes shut as Matt made slow, careful thrusts, mindful of what I was feeling. He grabbed my cock and told me to relax, giving it a few rough tugs. Getting the idea, I grabbed my cock from him, stroking myself the way I know I like and pushing back against him. He took that as a hint to start going faster, and after a little while it started to feel really good, in a weird pleasure/pain sort of way. He got pretty rough, pressing me down into the mattress and holding my thighs so hard I thought it would leave bruises. I vaguely remember hearing Lys come. Then she started egging Matt on, telling him to fuck me harder, to which he obliged. It wasn't too long before he came, groaning out my name. It was so fucking hot. He finished me off pretty quickly with his hand and kissed me for the first time that night.

Afterwards, the three of us just laid on Lys's bed for a bit, kissing and chuckling at the general absurdity of what just happened. Lys said it was hot, and I had to agree. I went home later that night, and proceeded to have a sexuality crisis for the next week and a half, prompting me to consult r/sex for advice. Following their advice, I decided to forgo a label on my sexuality for the time being and called Matt this afternoon. He said he had a really great time and invited me over on Friday. Hoping for a repeat performance.

update here!