I (f)ucked (m)y ex-bf and his brother in one day and neither of them know (Jay and Evan update) | 2016

Part 1 - Almost Fucked My Boyfriend's Older Brother
Part 2 - Almost Fucked My Boyfriend's Older Brother AGAIN

Part 3 - FINALLY Fucked My Boyfriend's Older Brother

Read parts 1-3 to get caught up in the whole story. I'm going to get this out of the way... Yes, I'm a horrible person for all of this. Let's acknowledge that and just enjoy the sexy details, mmkay?

Sooo.. part 3 happened about a month ago. Since then, Jay and I have had mindblowing sex every single time we have fucked and he continues to get my pussy wet and throbbing with very little effort. My pussy is constantly soaking wet at the thought of fucking him... I might write a few of them up for you some other time.

Anyway, a few days ago... Jay and I had plans to basically fuck all morning. So I went over to his place with some coffee... he gave me a key, so I just walked right in and he was still asleep. I love waking up someone with sex, so I stipped of all of my clothes and got into bed with him, under the blankets. He was wearing a very thin, loose-fitting pair of boxers and when I reached for his dick, he already had morning wood. His eyes open slightly and he sees me, smiling. Mmm... you smell so good he mumbles as he quickly grabs my ass and starts squeezing it, rubbing himself on to me and dry humping me while I kiss his neck and around his face. He lifts me up so I'm now straddling him and I start grinding on his dick while he is playing with my tits. He can't believe how big they are for my frame and keeps moaning and biting his lips while he cups them in his hand, kneading and every now and then, he would squeeze and roll my nipples so it hurt just a little bit. I'm enjoying myself, letting my clit find his cock and I'm rocking back and forth on him.. mmm... ohh He plays with them for about a minute until I had to see, touch and taste his beautiful, big dick. I have had lots of PMs on how big it is.. I would say about 9-10 inches. It is HUGE. The width is average and he has a very nice upward curve to it that drives me crazy. Just imagining it right now is getting me incredibly wet.. Anyway, I pull his cock out of the front hole of his boxers and start slowly jerking him off. It's so smooth and perfect... I keep my hand on the bottom of his dick, I start licking his head, bobbing up and down and getting it nice and wet. My spit is slowly rolling down to the rest of his cock and I use it as lubrication as I give him a handjob, while I keep his head in my mouth, still bobbing up and down, now going a little further than the head, but not letting him hit the back of my throat. I sync the rhythm of my mouth with my hand and I'm moaning on him like crazy. I can tell he likes it... His breathing is getting heavier, he reaches over and starts pulling my hair, trying to control my head... he's dying for me to fully take him in my mouth and I love to tease.... I keep licking him up and down, giving his balls some attention with my tongue. All the while, moaning all over his cock. When I lick from his balls to the tip and I am getting ready to take his tip into my mouth again, swirling my tongue around it... he pushes my head down and he basically chokes me with his rock hard cock by quickly shoving my head down as he thrusted up into my mouth. He keeps thrusting, slowly at first. I'm gagging and moaning at the same time, this was so fucking hot to me. I come up for air and he sees there's tears in my eyes and he says sorry... but I tell him to keep going and to fuck my mouth until you cum... I slowly put his dick back in my mouth and he keeps pushing me down and letting me gag on it over and over again. This is getting both of us pretty hot and he cums while he's still deep in my throat. I swallow every drop and I lick him clean while he's super sensitive and we both realize he's still pretty hard... So I took of his boxers and climbed on top of him. I hold his dick up against my pussy lips and I use the tip of his head to touch my clit... masturbating with his rock hard cock. It was slipping everywhere... I was so wet that I had cum dripping down the inside of my thighs and my cum was now coating his again, fully hard dick. I finally can't take it anymore and I lower myself... I'm still holding his dick when I position my soaking wet pussy on him and I take him in slowly. He's muttering, fuck... your pussy feels so fucking good... so fucking tight and am loving it, so I decide to go a little faster... and faster. My hands are on my tits, squeezing and bringing them up so I could lick my own nipples... and he starts using his thumb on my clit and it's driving me wild. He says make yourself cum on my cock and I do as he says... I am so loud when I cum, I don't even care that his neighbors could hear. Aww fuck fuck fuck... oh my god. I bent down to kiss him and he flips me over on all fours. He positions us beside his mirror... so we could see ourselves if we turn to our left. I could see myself and I look amazing in the mirror... tone, tanned body and my ass sticks up while my tits are hanging down in front of me, they are nice and firm and so smooth. He reaches over to play with them as he very slowly enters my incredibly wet pussy. Once he's in, he says holy fuck... you are so fucking wet.. how is this possible and he loses himself while fucking me. He's fucking me hard, fast and he's slapping my ass while I'm playing with my clit. I love when guys lose all control and just fuck me. Hes moaning out loud with me, we're both pretty close to a huge orgasm... I look at the mirror and tell him, you look so fucking hot fucking me like that... and he just loses it. He leans back, tells me to put my hands on my back and he uses them as a "handle" to fuck me fast and hard until I came HARD... he then pulled out and jerked himself off as he came on my ass and my back, with his cum pooling on my back dimples. He hands me a towel, I clean up and we fucked one more time before I left to go home to shower.

Fast forward to that evening, when I get a random phone call from Evan. We have been broken up about 2 months now and we went from being FWB, to not talking at all, to somewhat speaking (small talk) so it was strange to see his name on my phone. We were both seeing others, but he had NO IDEA Jay and I were even friends or that we had talked outside of hanging out him. (He actually almost caught us a couple of weeks ago, but that's another story.) Anyway, I pick up the phone and he said he was just down the street and wanted to come talk to me. So I said sure, come over. No one else was home, anyway.

I didn't think anything of this visit, but just in case... I wore a nice top that revealed my boobs, no bra, which he loves, and a pair of black yoga pants. Within 15 minutes, he's ringing the doorbell and I'm suddenly very, very nervous. I remember my hands were sweaty as I went to open the door!! He looked amazing. He looked happier, new clothes (probably due to the new girl he's been seeing) and he smelled amazing... I then realized how much I really missed him and secretly hoped he came over to fuck me. We do an awkward hug and we head to the living room, where he sits down on the opposite end of the couch from me. I turn it on just so there's something on and it's not total silence. The sexual tension is definitely there. I ask him what was up and we both start updating each other on what we've been up to... how our families are, how's school and work, etc. We are both extremely honest with each other and eventually, I tell him I've been fucking someone, a new fuck buddy of mine. He asks where I met him, and I lie and said I met him at work. I give him no other detail. He tells me he's still seeing some girl... he also met her from his work. Technically, that should have squashed all the sexual tension, right? But it did the opposite... The thought of him absolutely destroying some random's girl's pussy was a huge turn on for me and it must have been the same for him, because I noticed he started to get hard under his pants. I take this as a sign and I move in closer, putting my hand on his thigh. He doesn't brush it away, so I keep it there, rubbing up and down while we chatted. His dick was visibly getting harder as we talked and I swear I saw it twitch when he looked down my shirt. It started to feel very overwhelming (and I was soooo confused at this point) so I turned to get up "to get us some drinks". He follows me into the kitchen and I know he was staring at my ass. I'm on the counter, cutting some fruit, when I feel his hands on my hips at first... he pushes himself very close to me, so I could now feel his rock hard cock on my ass. I am NOT moving at this point, frankly because I was so confused. But also because this was a huge turn on and I didn't know what to do with myself (the guilt of having just fucked his brother a few hours before was in my mind... but the way he felt right now, made me almost forget.) His hands move from my hips, to my sides and he's slowly going up to my breasts. He cups them and I let out a moan, put down what I was doing and just enjoy him feeling me up. He starts kissing the back of my neck, my shoulders and he turns me around to kiss me. We kiss and it's fucking electric. My hands are in his hair, our tongues are going crazy and I'm biting his lip. Evan is slightly taller than Jay and he is very fit. He plays football and spends most of his free time lifting. I am tiny (5'4), so he lifts me up on the counter, takes off my shirt and starts flicking his tongue on my nipples while playing with them. Oh my god, it was amazing. I couldn't help it, I slowly reached down into my yoga pants to touch myself... but he stopped me. Instead he picked me up, while we are kissing and I'm dry humping him with my legs wrapped around him, he moved me back to the living room. Puts me down and takes off my pants... he then eats me out and it is amazing. His tongue felt familiar on my clit, the way he licked and sucked and spanked my little pussy felt sooo good. But... I was a little distracted. At this point, I am thinking that oh shit, we're going to fuck. And OMG I just fucked Jay this morning and I started to feel very, very guilty about it all. I start thinking, maybe I'll just give him a blowjob? We can fuck another day, but not today. Before I even get a gameplan in my head, Evan is taking off his clothes and he's now fully naked in front of me. Mmmm, his cock was rock hard, leaking precum and it was standing straight up. My pussy was throbbing, aching for him... so my plans to not fuck him got thrown out the window right there.

He wasted no time. He bent down to kiss me and I could feel his cock on my pussy, so I start grinding on him. I whisper I want you... and in seconds, he picked me up from the couch and carried me against a wall.... (I loooove tall guys and how they can carry me around) once we reach the wall, we looked at each other and started kissing again as he slowly entered my throbbing, wet cunt. I let out a loud ohhhhhhh fuuuuuckkk once he was in... he was in soo deep. Even though he's a little smaller than Jay, he had a way with fucking me. He knew what I liked and he always fucking delivered. He knew I liked things slow at first, so that's what he did... he slowly fucked me and my pussy wrapped around and squeezed his dick as I came. His balls were covered in my cum and it started to drop down my thighs. He then moved me back on the couch and we fucked missionary at first, but I moved to my legs up on top of his shoulders. He kept fucking me like this, while I played with my clit. He loves seeing my eyes roll back and when I get lost on my own... so I let it all go. I was circling my clit and talking dirty to him as he fucked me... my eyes closed. He started to go very fast and he moved my legs to the side. So he was fucking me sideways, but had the perfect view of my bouncing tits as he fucked me. He squeezed one with his hand as he closed his eyes and I could feel I was close. I tell him to keep going yess, fuck me.. oooh, cum for me. cum in my pussy, baby... and he let out a huge fuuuuuuuckkk as we both came. We did not lay there together for long... my guilt started the moment right after I came. We kissed after and I told him I had plans that night, so he couldn't stay. (I lied.) So he left and we both said we'd call each other.

This happened 2 days ago and I have not seen either one of them since. Just been re-living everything in my head, trying to figure out what to do next. I have already decided that neither of them can ever find out that they fucked me on the same day. They have both messaged and called me, but I keep making excuses not to see them. Jay said he might come over tonight after NYE since I'm having a huge party at my place, and I want him to... but... I don't know. Anyway this sub has become my little diary on this and it feels so good to just type all of this shit down. I literally have NO ONE to talk to about this and it sucks. Sooo I guess thanks... ya pervs! ;)

I like PMs, if you have any specific questions on this or just want to keep my mind off them...