Foursome with mystery friends [mmff] | 2016

My boyfriend had been teasing me with the promise of a threesome for a while. We had discussed it at length and we agreed it was something we both wanted, but he loved to take charge and he insisted that he should make it happen on his own. I was to have no say in the where or when. Even the who he would arrange by himself. He did ask me for a list of people that I would agree to have sex with, but he had insisted on it being a fairly long list and some of the names on there I wasn’t one hundred percent sure how they would work out.

Physically they were all perfectly delicious-looking boys and girls, but it was the afterwards that worried me about some of them. One of the girls for instance was in grad school with me and I could just picture myself giving a seminar with her sitting in the front row biting her lower lip because she knew things about me that maybe she shouldn’t. And the boys, well… boys like to brag don’t they? I wasn’t sure how discreet some of them would be!

All of this made me nervous but in a good way. This was something fun and exciting and I trusted my boyfriend and I knew he would look out for me, even though I also knew he liked to tease and push my limits every once in a while. Like on that Wednesday a couple of weeks earlier, when he had told me that the threesome would happen that night...

Wednesday night is the night that I go to the pool of my local YMCA with my swim club. Swimming always makes me relaxed and energized and my boyfriend and I always have sex afterward. That night just before I left he told me that he’d be waiting for me at our place and that he wouldn’t be alone... That got me so excited I spent the whole hour in the pool thinking about what would happen when I got home! I kept looking around to see who was there and who wasn’t, and who was leaving early! There were a few people from the swim club on the list I’d given my boyfriend a few weeks back. Like Jennifer for instance. She was tall and svelte and she had the best body of all the girls at the pool. She wasn’t there that night. Could she be at my place right now with my boyfriend, waiting for me? What were they doing while I was still at the pool? Surely they wouldn’t be doing anything without me? Just thinking about it made me want to get out of the water and hurry home! Or what about Eduardo? He wasn’t at the pool that night either. He was tall and handsome and he had tried to seduce me when we first met, before I told him I had a boyfriend. He wasn’t on my list but could my boyfriend somehow have found out about Eduardo and offered him to get into bed with us? My boyfriend straying away from the list wouldn’t surprise me one bit. It was exactly the kind of thing he loved to do to push my buttons!

The hour in the water sure dragged on! I usually stay afterwards to socialize but this time I showered quickly and rushed home. On the walk upstairs to our apartment I was so nervous I was shaking! My knees were a bit weak when I slid the key in and opened the door…

My boyfriend must have heard me come up because he greeted me at the door. He asked if I was ready to do this. I nodded. He pulled a blindfold out of his back pocket and put it over my eyes. That wasn’t something we’d discussed! He then undressed me right there by the front door and took me to our bedroom. He told me to turn around and bend over with my hands on my ankles. “Show our guest how great your ass looks” he said. I love a guy who takes charge! I complied happily. I felt so exposed with my ass up in the air like that. Who was the stranger looking at me? Would he be gentle? Would he caress my ass and lick me? Or would he fuck me hard and use me? I didn’t even know if it was a man or a woman looking at me! The tension was driving me crazy! I could feel myself getting wetter and wetter, the moisture slowly seeping out of me. Could they see that? Surely they could… What were they thinking? Did they think I was a slut for being so turned on by people staring at my ass?

Before my thoughts could get carried away even more I felt two hands grab my hips firmly and a hard cock plunge hard into my pussy. It was a weird position bent over like that but it felt so good! I began to moan as the stranger behind me wasted no time and just immediately started fucking me hard. I didn’t even know who it was? Was it my boyfriend or some other boy? The touch was familiar but there was no way to be sure! If it was my boyfriend, who was it that was watching us? What were they doing while we fucked?

The man behind me kept pounding at me and soon my knees were buckling and I was on all fours. He didn’t miss a beat and kept at it, still thrusting in long, hard, powerful strokes. The evening’s anticipation had gotten me so turned on it wasn’t long before I could feel an orgasm building up! I moaned louder and the stranger’s hand was on my clit, sending waves of pleasure all over me. Wet fingers licked at my clit and the waves got bigger and more intense until a moment later I was awash in one of the most earth-shaking orgasm I’d felt in a long time! My knees were shaking and my thighs were spazzing before I collapsed, spent, on the hardwood floor.

I stayed there a while, too spent to move, before my boyfriend’s voice took me out of my stupor. “You can take the blindfold off now” Curious to see who else was there with us I removed it and… there was no one! Just my boyfriend and me! It wasn’t a threesome at all! That amazing, momentous orgasm had been just from the anticipation alone! He stood there above me with this big grin on his face and I didn’t know if I should be mad at him for deceiving me like that or not. “Well at least now we know you’re really into it!” The jerk! As if I didn’t already know that!

So on that other Wednesday two weeks later when he told me that this time, for real, the threesome would happen that night, I wasn’t sure what to believe. He wasn’t one to pull the same prank twice, but he might well try to pull another one! Still, I spent another long hour in the pool peeking around to see who was in attendance that night and who was absent. Eduardo was there I noticed, but Jennifer was again nowhere to be found.

The walk home was just as nerve-racking as the one two weeks earlier, but this time I managed the walk up the stairs more easily. I slid my key inside the keyhole, opened the door and… there was nobody there! Just the blindfold on the floor with a note “You know the drill”. What was he thinking!? Did he really expect me to walk in there naked and blindfolded!? My heart was racing so fast it took me a moment before I could gather myself and start taking off my clothes. Before I was finished my boyfriend appeared. After a few words he helped me put the blindfold on and he walked me to the bedroom.

Again I stood in front of an unknown stranger with my hands holding on to my ankles and my ass in the air for all to see. Again my juices were trickling down my thigh when strong hands grabbed my hips and a cock entered me from behind. This time I was pretty sure it was my boyfriend. It was just too familiar. It felt nice but I was starting to think there was once again no one there with us in the room... But just as I was considering the possibility another hand grabbed my hair and gently but firmly pulled my head up!

The man pulling me up was strong and there was no resisting him as he shoved his hard cock into my mouth. I gasped in surprise (a good surprise!) and immediately he pushed himself to the back of my throat. I almost gagged! Thankfully he pulled out and let me recover for a second. When he pushed in again I was ready. My mouth opened for him and my throat took him in and I closed my lips tightly around his shaft. Now that’s a real threesome! I was so excited that we were finally doing it after all the build up, and with a guy to boot! I like girls too but I was so happy to have two boys all to myself tonight!

The three of us dropped to our knees and one stranger (my boyfriend I was almost sure) pounded my pussy while the other one fucked my mouth. Although I tried this was no blowjob! He was fucking so hard and strong all I could manage was to keep my lips tight around his cock while he dictated the pace. The stranger behind had one finger over my asshole and another on my clit, and the one in front had both hands in my hair to guide my mouth over his cock. They fucked both ends of me passionately and the tension quickly built up inside of me. I stood on the edge for a long time, fighting it because I didn’t want it to end so soon! But when one hand let go of my hair and pinched and pulled at my nipples I was done for! I could no longer stop it. The dam broke and I was shaking and moaning around the cock in my mouth. When my orgasm finally subsided the two strangers released me and I stayed there on hands and knees, my dripping mouth open to catch my breath. But I didn’t stay there long!

They weren’t finished with me yet! They pulled me up and gently laid me down on the bed. Even though I had just orgasmed I started getting excited again at the thought of what else they had planned for me! Two hands parted my legs and I felt the mattress bend under the weight of someone climbing up between my legs.

I felt soft hands on my thighs, long hair on my belly and soft, soft lips between my legs! I tensed up a bit because I’d never had a girl go down on me before but her tongue was magic and I relaxed instantly. Her tongue teased and prodded, it flicked and licked at my still-sensitive lips, it lapped in wide, intense strokes until I just had to ask her to “Please lick my clit…” I was a bit shy and for some reason my voice came out a whimpery squeak but she heard me just the same and I didn’t have to repeat it. I gasped and my legs closed uncontrollably around her head when her tongue made contact. I was well on my way to orgasm number two when she drew back. I moaned my complaint but thankfully she didn’t stop for long!

She turned around and got on all fours above me with her thighs on either side of my face. Immediately her tongue was back on my clit and my hands latched on to the soft muscle of her ass. My tongue reached out to return the favor but she was high enough she was just out of reach. Before I could try again the mattress was wobbling under the weight of two more people joining us.

One stranger put his hands right over mine as he entered the girl above me. The other was between my legs and his hard cock slid gently inside my pussy. The two of them started thrusting slowly, first each of them following his own rhythm, but soon syncing up with both fucking us at the same pace. Even though I couldn’t see anything the mental vision of the four of us in my bed was driving me wild! I couldn’t see but I could hear and I could feel and I could smell... Her flowery perfume mixed with the scent of her sex right above me and filled my nostrils. Her moans filled my ears. Her ass filled my hands...

And I could feel the boys too! The way they made the bed shake with each thrust. Their muffled grunts and groans. The way that hard cock just above my head slid inside her, and the way the other one filled me, with wide strong hips pushing against my spread legs. All that and the magic of the girl’s tongue combined and it wasn’t long before I was coming again! I shaked and I moaned and my hands held on tight to the girl’s ass! Meanwhile the three others didn’t stop. The girl was still lapping at my clit but more and more erratically as the boy thrusted into her faster and faster. My orgasm subsided and I concentrated on her. I licked my fingers and felt above me for her clit. When I found it I massaged it softly. I could only guess how she wanted me to touch her but the sound of her moans guided my fingers!

Soon her own orgasm was washing over her. Her thighs twitched and her ass bobbed up and down above me. Her hair swept my thighs and my belly and my hips. And soon after that the two boys were coming too! The bed was rocking gently under buckling knees as their cum came gushing out of them.

When it was clear it was all over I went to remove my blindfold but my boyfriend stopped me. His hands pinned my wrists. “Not yet” he said. I heard shuffling around in the bedroom, then outside the bedroom and the bedroom door slammed shut. When I finally took the blindfold off the room was dark and it was just my boyfriend and me. A few minutes later the front door opened and closed and the two strangers were gone. “Who were they?” I asked. “People you know. People you trust. People who will keep their mouth shut about it.” he said. “Will you ever tell me?” He just smiled. “Maybe. Do you really want to know?” Did I? I figured it wouldn’t hurt to keep it a secret, at least for a while... That night was some of the best sex I ever had. But for a long time after that, whenever I saw Jennifer at the pool, or that grad student at my university, I always blushed a little and wondered what they knew about me.