Craigslist girl 1.5 | 2016

After one week of us messing around I decided to give the back door a try. She was riding me moaning spinning her head around. I figured since she was so into it she may not mind the extra pleasure. I didn’t tell I would and I put a finger on it and started to rub it. I didn't put it in at first I just keep rubbing it. Then I moved it a bit and got some of her pussy juices to “lube” my finger then I put in just about to the first knuckle. She did a little scream stop moving and said.

CL girl: what do you think you are doing?

Me: Nothing

CL girl: don’t even think about it I don’t do anal

My finger still in her ass I wiggle it a bit.

Me: So you don’t like how that feels

She took a deep breath.

CL girl: mmm yeah but that’s it you are not going deep or putting your dick there.

She keep riding me and I keep playing with her ass until she came. Kind of quick I must add.

A few days passed and it was Friday night. She had a party to go to, I didn't go with her because well I’m just hitting that so I didn't care. I’m at my place putting together a computer desk I got, and my phone started ringing. She’s calling me asking me if I can pick her up at the party. I went over I called her when I was outside of the club. She came out looking sexy as hell and she was with her friend… Oh yeah yer friend damn her friend looked good as hell too. The CL girl was drunk as fuck as I was driving she keep trying to kiss me I keep looking at her friend on the back seat. I was wondering if maybe I could get this two together. That didn't happen I had to drop her off at her place. When I got to my place CL girl was still all over me. Got to my room and she took off all her clothes and pulled down my sweatpants she almost got on me before I put the condom on. She just started riding me like crazy and moaning and screaming like crazy. I figure mmm let me see what happen. I tried to put my finger in her ass. I put my middle finger in just up to the knuckle like before but to my surprise, she grabbed my hand and pushed my finger all the way in. I keep fingering her ass while she was riding me and my plan was to flip her around and stick my dick up her ass.

Before I could do that she came. Got off me layed down and passed out. She was there laying on her side pussy dripping. I thought I could prob just fuck her as she is passed out but that would be rape. So I didn’t. Next morning I told her what happen she looked at me and told me.

CL girl: So I did that and you didn’t fuck me in the ass?

Me: No that’s not right but when you had my fat finger as deep as I could push it in you loved it.

CL girl: really wow

Me: so you see you would love anal

CL girl: no don’t push it I’m not doing it.

One of the reasons why not long after that I dumped her ass. Anything is else I could write about her is just drama so this will end the stories of the CL girl. I got some other girls stories. Will post them soon. Also for the hell of it I wrote a different version of this story. I'll post it too but that one has a bit of fantasy on it. I figure I'll post this one the real one first and then the "modified" one.