College Experience: Three, or Four, of a Kind (M/F/F) (F/F) | 2016

Chronologically, the following events happened the second semester of my sophomore year, directly after the events detailed here: http://www.reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/1yg07f/college_experience_caught_with_my_mostly_gay/

Yes, they really happened. This is the story of what can only be called my first orgy.

It all started innocently enough. I was in my sophomore year of college and things couldn't have been going better. I had a beautiful girlfriend who my parents loved and I was rapidly falling for, my grades were good, and the job prospects for the future were looking up. I'd had a few interviews and was confident I could get something over the summer.

For those of you just joining us, my girlfriend, Haley, had natural honey blond hair, pretty green eyes, gorgeous legs topped topped by a well rounded ass, a nice of well rounded C cups, cute dimples, a modest tan, and a truly beautiful smile. We cared about each other a lot and got along splendidly. She was a very "wholesome" girl and had an incredibly sexy "girl next door" thing going on. She was also "predominantly homosexual, but more than incidentally heterosexual." She didn't feel that she could give up on women entirely, so as part of our relationship, she agreed to avoid sleeping with other men and notify me anytime she slept with a woman. At the time, I'd say she averaged one new girl every month or so.

Every time she slept with a girl, she would tell me about it in exquisite detail. Sexually, Haley was normally very submissive, but on occasion would become very dominant which apparently is a big turn on for a lot of lesbians. The vast majority of her stories were about her getting seduced and fucked by other female students of the college. It didn't take her long to figure out that I found these stories very arousing to me to say the least.

One night, after telling me about her latest conquest, she blushed more than usual and dropped a bombshell on me by simply stating, in an adorably legalistic tone that showed she'd thought about it a lot: "I've been a lot thinking about what it might be like to have another woman with us at some point. Is that something you've ever thought about or might want to talk about as a possibility with me?"

Like any other young man, I had numerous fantasies about getting my smoking hot girlfriend to have a threesome with me. So of course I promptly answered "Yes, absolutely." She actually sounded relieved...as if any man on the planet would have turned down that offer... and said "Great. We'll have to pick an appropriate girl then."

Haley and I then had a long discussion about what turned both of us on in a women. For me, the answer could be summed up in one word "tits." For her, it was a little more complicated. My experience with women strongly suggests that for them, things are always a little more complicated. Apparently, she was also a fan of breasts and tall chicks (she wouldn't get any argument from me there), but most of her things were personality based. She liked dominant girls basically. She emphasized that this wouldn't happen overnight and I should be patient, which I was more than willing to be.

That weekend, on our weekly date night she let me know that she had met a girl named Katie that week in the college's library. (Note: This was not my friend Katie.) Katie had seduced Haley almost immediately, and the two of them had fucked in the library's bathroom. They had had sex several times since and apparently it had been incredible...the best she'd ever had with a women. (Haley repeatedly has claimed that sex with a girl and sex with a guy were so different as to not be comparable. Given future events, this may have been to protect my feelings.)

Another week passed and Haley kept talking about all the amazing sex she was having with her fuck buddy Katie to the point where I actually started to get a little jealous. Finally, my curiosity outweighed my jealously and I asked if I could meet this Katie. Haley said "Sure" but warned me that Katie wouldn't be interested in my in the slightest. I told her that it was fine.

The three of us scheduled dinner at the cafeteria. Meeting my girlfriend's female fuck buddy was undoubtedly one of the weirdest experiences of my life. The first thing I noticed was that Haley's fuck buddy was a knockout. Katie was a bottle blond with a heart shaped face, striking blue eyes, creamy white skin, and a very respectable C cup in the tits department. Despite her feminine appearance however, she was one of the most assertive people I have ever met in my life. She felt perfectly comfortable talking about screwing my girlfriend in a relatively crowded cafeteria. It was easy to see why she'd taken to dominating Haley in the sack. At one point, she even describe Haley as "my current bitch." The only thing we could bond over was our mutual semi-loathing of Haley's roommate Izzi who was apparently being just as big a pain to Katie as she had been to me. After hearing about Izzi's insane interruption of Haley and myself Katie described the roommate as a "total cunt." The entire experience could only be described as surreal and my jealously of the fact that Katie was dominating Haley was only outweighed by my arousal about it.

As the weeks passed Haley's stories of Katie only got more dramatic and took a turn towards the crazy. It also became increasingly obvious that Haley was excluding some of the details of the stories. But, if she was happy, I was happy, or so I kept telling myself. By this point the semester was really flying by and my 20th birthday was approaching, ironically I was born on April, 15... which is tax day for any non-American readers. Haley was determined to have a party I "wouldn't soon forget." Well, THAT was an interesting phrase that conjured up all sorts of fantasies, particularity those associated with her earlier wish to add in a woman to our love-making.

Finally, Tax Day/my birthday arrived. Haley, who had deliberately kept me in the dark in regards to what would be happening, finally informed me that she had organized a 7 person game of Texas Hold 'Em strip poker in her dormroom. (At the time, I, and the rest of the world, was really into poker.) Of the seven people who came, five of them were female and the only other male was a close friend of mine named Calvin. (This was Mr. I-Need-To-Borrow-A-Condom guy from my last story.) The five women were Katie and Haley, both of whom I've already described. Katie was wearing an elaborate set up with fancy gloves and a small black backpack for some reason. Haley was also wearing an abnormally high amount of clothing. Melissa, another all-American short haired bottle-blond hair, blue eyed, busty (smaller D cups) bombshell who was on my freshman hall, Sam, the pretty brunette RA who told Izzi to bug off last time, and Kelly (not Kelli) a average looking friend of Haley's who apparently lived in the room next door and shared a connected bathroom with Haley. Clearly there were to many blonds at the table.

One thing I learned about strip poker immediately is that, after actually talking the object of your desire into playing, spending the next 3 hours discussing the rules kinda sucks, and not in the good way. First of all, we had plenty of alcohol (yes, I was 20, not 21...get over it) to lubricate the situation. At the start of the game we made a very clear arrangement that anyone could back out anytime they started feeling uncomfortable.

The rules were relatively simple, but if you aren't a poker player, feel free to gloss over them. Each player was given a whopping 10 starting chips. The game and betting rounds are played in the classical fashion, with big blinds of 4 and small blinds of 2, bets, raises, everything as usual. If, however, a player lost all of his or her chips, he or she had the opportunity to buy 5 more in exchange for taking off an item of clothing and taking a drink. Additionally, any player who went to the showdown and lost, you automatically lost an item of clothing and took a drink. (We were drinking beer btw.)There was not buying back clothing until you left the game. If you ran out of clothing and chips, you could opt to do a truth or dare from the person who had won last to get 5 more chips. If you refused to answer or do the dare, you only got 1 chip. (If you ever play a game of strip poker, I highly suggest this version, as it is relatively simple and pretty fun.)

Now, as you may have guessed, I'm actually pretty good at poker. With so many players, going to the showdown was foolish, unless you had a really good hand. I stayed very quiet initially and managed to snag a bunch of chips on a three of a kind. Haley, on the other hand...sucked at poker. It quickly became evident that she was either trying to lose, or had genuinely no idea what she was doing. She bled chips and articles of clothing like they were going out of style and, despite wearing an elaborate outfit with many layers that technically counted as articles, she was soon reduced to only her shirt and skirt. Kelly, Sam, and Calvin also seemed to have no idea what they were doing and rapidly started running out of layers. Both Katie and Melissa seemed competent.

Haley managed to win a hand and keep her shirt on, which caused Calvin to be the first one topless. A lot of woof whistling and catcall occurred, and he was relatively cool about the whole thing. Kelly went braless next, than bottomless, next. She was a nice girl, but she wasn't particularly good looking. However, Calvin, who by now was getting pretty drunk, obviously saw something he liked. The very next hand he made an ill advised bet against me and lost his boxers. The catcalls continued as the dropped them and revealed that he was already quite aroused. The hand after that, he went to the showdown again and lost. He laughed it off and said "Dare." Haley who had won and was still remarkably mostly clothed, dared him to kiss Kelly. The two of them went at it pretty passionately until the rest of us made a point of coughing to break them up. The very next hand was lost by Kelly to Katie. Katie wasn't one to fool around, she promptly dared Kelly to "Go into your bedroom with Calvin, stay there for 10 minutes, and see what comes up." Roughly five minutes later we heard hushed moaning and the squeaking of a bed. It was pretty obvious that they were going at it. We didn't see either one of them for the rest of the evening. They even left their clothing in Haley's room.

The five of us all had a good laugh about Calvin and Kelly's abrupt departure, then returned to the game. I lost a shoe to some seriously bad luck, but Haley was the one to pick up the chips, which she REALLY needed. The game turned against Sam, quickly, who began losing rapidly. Upon stripping down to her bra and panties, she stated that she wasn't comfortable any more (probably because Calvin and Kelly were having really loud sex next door), grabbed her clothing and left.

Now, only Katie, myself, Haley, and Melissa remained in the game. Everybody quieted down and things got sort of serious...or at least as serious as you can be when you are half drunk. I had a run of bad luck and lost my shirt to Katie, but quickly regained my lost chips (I didn't know we'd be playing, so I had very few articles of clothing on). Haley lost her shirt, then her skirt, leaving her only her bra and panties. However, she managed to take a bit of her own back from Melissa, who was promptly stripped down to her underwear and certainly looked good doing it. Then something magnificent happened...Katie started betting....and losing badly to me and Melissa. Her vast fortune depleted in a handful of turns and soon she began shedding clothing.

Finally, after nearly 30 minutes of play, Haley lost her top. Her amazingly perky breasts seemed to entice Melissa, who actually asked to touch them. Haley permitted her to do so and it was obvious from a stain on her panties that she was quite turned on. The very next hand Haley went to the showdown and lost again. She placed her panties on the table with great relish and declared it to be open season. I had a few good rounds against Katie and suddenly controlled the majority of the chips. Then, Haley lost her first pantie-less showdown to Melissa. Haley elected to go with a truth. Melissa asked "Am I the only person here you haven't slept with?" Haley responded "Yes." Melissa's fortunes proved shortlived though; as she soon lost her chips and her bra to me (when you have a lot of chips it is REALLY easy to win.) Melissa's breasts were pretty darn nice...large, but not too large and not too droopy. They had that heft and springiness that just screamed "All natural." Overall, they were an exceptional rack...but I personally preferred Haley's. The very next hand Haley lost again to Katie and chose dare. Katie dared Haley to suck on Melissa's newly exposed nipple. Haley looked at me and said "Its not cheating if we're both involved right?" I of course agreed and watched Haley attack Melissa's chest.

After some sucking, and a lot of groping with some minor moans escaping Melissa's mouth, Haley returned to her seat. By this point I was rock hard. The entire situation, plus the copious amounts of alcohol, had combined to created an atmosphere which just oozed sex. We continued to play the game, which promptly resulted in Melissa losing her panties to Haley, then rapidly losing again to Katie. Seeing the look in Katie's eyes, Melissa picked truth. Katie asked "What is your naughtiest, darkest, and most secret sex fantasy?"

I could see the wheel's in Melissa's head turning to decide if she wanted to answer or not. Finally her eyes modestly glazed over and she began "Well, I've always kinda had weird ones. I always really wanted to get bent over something solid, then fucked by a chick with a dick" She blushed and then hurriedly said "Or, you know, the two dudes at a time could be fun." After hearing something so....oddly specific... the game progressed. Essentially, Haley and Melissa had no chips and no way of easily getting them. I beat Haley next and asked her the same question. She admitted that she wanted to get "double teamed" by a guy and a chick. I felt pretty confident that we could make that happen by the end of the night.

I went on another winning streak which allowed me to ask Haley which position she preferred most, doggy btw and asked Melissa the number of sexual partners she'd had, nine. I got Katie down to her underwear, then she took control of the game again. By this point both Katie and I were getting frustrated with Haley and Melissa ALWAYS choosing truth. I retaliated against Melissa by asking "Imagine you’re going to hook up with the person you’ve wanted more than anyone. Walk me through your perfect seduction of that person." It turned out her person was Scarlet Johansson or Robert Downey Jr. (Iron Man was about to come out) Katie went right to the point and asked Melissa who the last person she masturbated to was (stunningly, also Scarlet Johansson)...I guess the girl had a type and stuck to it.

The game continued until Haley finally lost to me and selected "dare." Thrilled, and realizing that this was the moment of truth, I dared my amazing girlfriend to go down on Melissa for the duration of the next hand. Haley replied "Certainly" with a slight purr in her voice. Melissa hesitated at first, but the prospect of what was sure to be good oral sex brought her around and she agreed. Haley crawled under the very small table we were playing on and attacked Melissa's exposed pussy.

For that game, Melissa was obviously VERY distracted and lost horribly to me in the showdown. Haley stopped going down on her and returned to her seat. Melissa, still a little out of it, selected "dare." I dared her to return the favor to Haley who said "Awww....thank you honey" then enjoyed the, rather awkward, cunnilingus. It was incredibly hot to watch my beautiful girlfriend receive oral sex from another naked woman though, even if she apparently didn't know what she was doing.

Haley and Katie lost the showdown against me the next two times, finally revealing Katie's rather nice breasts to the world and causing Haley to accept another dare. I simply told her to do to Melissa what had been done to her. When Melissa lost to Katie the next round, she and Haley swapped positions again. Pretty soon, it was evident that Haley and Melissa had lost all interest in actually playing the game, as had both Katie and I. I was much more focused on watching the two busty beauties fingering and licking one another. The charge in the air was intense and I was hard as a rock just watching them.

Melissa had her head buried in my girlfriends beautiful pussy, and appeared to be happily lapping away when the inevitable happened. Katie walked over and tapped her on the shoulder. Despite protests from Haley, Melissa pulled her tongue out and took a short break from eating my girlfriend out. Katie gazed down at Melissa and my girlfriend and said "You two lost...you should accept our dares." Melissa began turning her head back to Haley's pussy when Katie continued with "I'm a chick with a dick...I dare you to bend over that dresser and get fucked." Melissa froze...then Katie finished with "That's your fantasy right?"

Haley, myself, and Katie stood in perfect silence while Melissa walked over to Haley's mirrored dresser and invitingly bent over it. She shot a glance back at Katie, and slapped her own ass. It was an obvious invitation that Katie wasted no time accepting. Katie walked over to Melissa and opened up the bag she'd brought with her. Then, she pulled out what I recognized from countless porno flicks as a harness and a huge strap on dildo. The thing must have been ten inches long.

I was stunned...I didn't know that real people actually used them. Haley helped Katie tighten the various straps and rub something that was obviously lub all over it. I stood in shocked silence watching Katie line it up. The first words I muttered after seeing the thing were "You didn't tell me about that" to Haley. She apologized profusely and swore to make it up to me. Hearing this, Katie now teasing the Melissa with her 5th limb, turned and said to me "I'll give you a hand with her after I tame this one." Then, Katie slid herself into Melissa,

Merely watching Katie's fake cock slide into and out of Melissa was quite simply entrancing. Melissa had an absolute death grip on that dresser and was arching her back into Katie's cock, letting out moans which could have woken the dead. It was an incredible sight, and Haley and I watched in awe. Katie then went into what I can only described as "dominant dirty talking mode." It quickly became apparent that Katie was some kind of crazy dominance junkie. She didn't just want to fuck Melissa...she wanted to "Make you [Melissa] my own personal fuck-toy, multipurpose bitch, and sex-slave." Katie claimed that it was her "sacred purpose to tame bitches." Apparently, this sort of talk really turned Melissa on because the moaning increased and she began frantically begging Katie to "take me harder."

The whole experience had me approaching diamond levels of hardness. I knew that I needed to have my way with Haley. Haley was watching Melissa's "taming" with a mix of undisguised lust and jealously in her eyes. I dragged her over to the bed, laided her down on it, and asked "Is that what Katie did to you?" Haley nodded, still watching the display. I pulled Haley's head towards me and deeply kissed her. I then asked "Does that sort of thing turn you on? Do you want me to try it?" Haley nodded frantically.

I smiled, then pulled her body to the edge of the bed. I spread her beautiful long legs apart, dropped to me knees, and began to eat her out. Haley's pussy was ridiculously wet and she almost instantly started screaming my tongue quickly darted from her clit to her pussy lips, then back to her clit again. She moan "Fuck me...now" softly. Of course, I was willing to oblige her.

I stuck a pillow under her ass to elevate it and quite easily slid, rather condom-less, into her. Haley's tight pussy was already pulsing when I entered it, a side effect of being eaten out and the entire situation. I could feel that she wanted it hard and fast...so of course I gave it to her slowly and sensually. As we developed our slow rhythm, it was obvious that she wanted it bad. Haley was arching her back into me to get my cock further inside of her. She had actually lifted her but up off the pillow to ensure more direct access. I increased the speed of our lovemaking moderately, which only made her want it more. Her pussy pulsed around my cock...ever so close but not QUITE at orgasm. I could physically feel her hovering on the edge.

I decided to push her over it. I kept myself inside her, but leaned my head down to kiss her passionately, then moved my lips to her ear and whispered "So watching Melissa get fucked into submission gets you going huh? " Haley nodded frantically, wrapped her long and gorgeous legs around my back, and replied "And I'd like to share her fate, so get that cock to work." I wrapped both hands around her ample ass and began thrusting deep into her. She started to scream my name, imploring me to go deeper, harder, and faster. I felt her tighten around my cock and her pussy began to pulse. I continued pumping myself into her. She let out a brief shout of "Yes! Tame that pussy" and came. Her eyes rolled back into her head and her pussy spasmed around me.

It was obvious that I couldn't keep it up much longer. The situation was just to damn hot, I mean, I was seriously fucking my beautiful girlfriend while her lesbian lover had sex with another hot chick a few feet away. In the middle of her orgasm her pussy's milking of my cock simply proved to be the straw which broke the metaphorical camel's back. I didn't just come inside her. I let myself detonate inside her, pumping into her, listening to her breathy moans become high pitched cries of delight as she clamped down on me. With a groan, I pushed my cock into her for the last time, draining my swollen balls with a bone-deep satisfaction into her, still orgasming, cunt. I turned my head to kiss her thighs lightly before lowering her legs from their position wrapped around my back. I leaned forward against both her and the headboard, panting and trying to catch my breath still inside her.

I glanced over at the other couple, only to see Katie pulling out of Melissa leaving her bent over and obviously used. Katie walked over to Haley and I, leaned down to get up to my ear and whispered "Doesn't your girlfriend have a great pussy? She's one hell of a fuck." Normally, I'd punch someone who said that, but I was just to tired and utterly spent. Katie licked my ear and said "Can I get some sloppy seconds?" I looked down at Haley to see her nodding frantically.

I reluctantly withdrew from Haley. Without my cock there to hold it in, my cum started dripping out of her pussy For some reason, the thought that I was about to watch my girlfriend get violated by another women while oozing my cum out of her tight little pussy really turned me on.

One thing you can say for Katie, she didn't waste any time. She flipped Haley over, shoved her down on all fours, raised her ass in the air, and had her into position about 20 seconds after I pulled out...seriously. Katie pressed her fake cock right up against Haley's slightly used pussy and began to tease it. Haley unleashed a series of moans and frantically tried to arch her back enough to get the thing into her. Katie however, managed to continue the teasing. Then, just when it became obvious that Haley was at the end of her rope, Katie asked "Do you want me to fuck you?" Haley let out a resounding "Yes!"

Katie smiled, delivered a sharp slap to my girlfriend' shapely ass and said "Come on...you know better than that...ask properly." Haley inquisitively responded "Yes, please?" Que another slap on the ass and Katie saying "You know what you need to do to get this." Haley seductively wiggled her ass, glanced back at Katie and said "Please Katie....take me like the bitch I am."

Katie began pounding my girlfriend with her strap on. Even naked, ALWAYS Haley looked as wholesome as a vanilla milkshake, 2% milk, Coca Cola, or apple pie on the 4th of July. This effect wasn't ruined by the fact that she was getting fucked by a strap on or that her eyes were literally rolling back into her head with pleasure. Watching my incredibly wholesome girlfriend get violated like that by another women tapped into something very deep inside me.

Apparently, I wasn't the only one. I heard a groan from the other corner of the room and turned to see Melissa watching Haley get "taken" and fingering herself to the sight. By this point, I was...excited...again...just at the entire situation. I wanted Haley again...quite badly.

My arousal didn't go unnoticed (its kinda hard for a guy to hide that sort of thing). Katie looked down at me and asked if I was "Ready to go again." I responded that yes, yes I was. Katie rolled her eyes and gestured towards Melissa said "Well, Haley's mine for now. Lucky for you I've got a spare tamed bitch." Cue moral confusion. I was really horny...like really really really horny...but I didn't want to cheat.

Seeing my indecision, Katie stopped screwing my girlfriend and said "Haley, tell him he can fuck the bitch." Haley locked her beautiful green eyes with mine and said "CollegeExp...it'd be really hot if you fucked her." Melissa stopped masturbating and said "I'm game if you hold it and get off outside." Well, that totally counted as "permission."

“How do you want to do this?” I asked Melissa.

She didn't answer. She positioned herself on the bed facing towards Katie. She just bent over, got down on her hands and knees and wiggled her ass at me seductively. Then she glanced back with a smirk. My mouth went dry. I hadn't had another women, much less a blond bombshell with D cups (as previously mentioned, I am a tit man) in what felt like forever (It had actually been a little more than two months.)

Now, at the time I always tried to follow the philosophy of "Two and then you" which my older brother had previously eloquently informed me meant "Get her off twice before you come at all. You'll be repaid in spades. Trust me." (Years later, I'm almost confident that this is complete and total BS as getting a women you just met to get off ONCE is challenging,) but at the time I believed in it completely, so I didn't start with the fucking. I was determined to give her two more before angling her hips up and shoving my cock in.

I started with fingers. Melissa's pussy just felt...different and looser than Haley's (which was an achievement considering all the sex Haley and I had been having.) She seemed to like it, but quickly demanded more. I tried to go down on her, but just as I started Haley called out "Come on...fuck her already." Well, I certainly wasn't going to deny my girlfriend, so I stood up and figured I'd go for two inside her.

As previously mentioned, Melissa wasn't particularly tight. To be honest, the sex was remarkably average (which is pretty bad considering my girlfriend was getting fucked by another women less than a foot away and that Melissa had a killer body.) I started off slowly, but she wasn't having any of that. Our rhythm started to accelerate as I pumped into her faster and faster and she arched her ass against my dick. I reached down and grabbed her rather large breasts, being uncharacteristically rough, and pretty much using them as handles to pump into her. That was a lot more intense, but it knocked her hands off balance, so she feel forward with her ass and pussy still sticking up in the air. The more direct angle caused her to let out another loud moan. I felt her pussy begin to pulse. It was obvious that she was getting off on this whole sitaution. I stayed in as long as I could...but even average sex with a hot girl is still a lot of fun and I couldn't hold off forever. I felt that distinct tightening of my balls and pulled out. I had ridden her hard and put her away wet. That was good enough.

I remember distinctly hearing Haley say "Holy shit, did she just get off? That was fast." and Melissa only groaning in response. I was right on the edge for a second, but started "calming down" before I could get off. My balls felt heavy and swollen and I didn't want to get back in Melissa for obvious reasons. I needed to get off. Then I noticed that Haley's mouth was only a short distance away. I needed to get off, so I went for it.

Now, here's a little bit of advice for anyone who is ever in a similar situation. "Spit roasting" as it is called is actually really freaking hard. It turns out that the two parties on either end need to time their thrusts. This isn't easy to do when everybody is drunk and horny (which is when the situation tends to happen of course.) After what felt like forever, Katie and I managed to figure it out. That being said, fucking my girlfriend while she got fucked by her girlfriend was really quite hot. I'd like to say that I was a sexual beast, but that would be a lie. I went off in Haley's mouth in less than a minute. Katie finished up soon after that.

With that the "magic" was gone. It turned out that we had made an enormous mess of the room which required a lot of cleaning up. The logistics alone of getting that much preparation off a bed are nothing to laugh at. Overall, it was a very enjoyable experience for me and a great "birthday present," though I still thought Katie was a very scary person. (She was. She "dumped" Haley for Melissa less than a day later.) I kissed Haley goodnight and returned to my apartment. After getting dumped by Katie I learned that Haley had simply LOVED the experience, and really wanted to try it again, but finding another partner would be another story.

Note: I'm sorry about the rather bad grammar here. Work is busy right now and I didn't get as much time to proofread it as I'd like.

Do you guys really enjoy these? I've got a lot more interesting, sexy, and downright funny stories (with trademark interjections in the form of parentheses inter-spaced in the middle of thoughts), but the reactions so far to most of my stuff have been wildly mixed. So, I just wanted to quickly gauge interest before I spent the time to write them up. If you are interested in seeing more of this sort of thing (I can think of at least 4 other events that are story worthy) let me know. Additionally, should I keep going chronologically, or is there anything special you guys would like to read? Let me know below.